Added graphs and continued work on the proximal decoding results section
This commit is contained in:
parent
8b3354bd45
commit
a07fed6cbb
@ -1,7 +1,12 @@
|
||||
\chapter{Proximal Decoding}%
|
||||
\label{chapter:proximal_decoding}
|
||||
|
||||
TODO
|
||||
In this chapter, the proximal decoding algorithm is examined.
|
||||
First, the algorithm itself is described.
|
||||
Then, some interesting ideas concerning the implementation are presented.
|
||||
Simulation results are shown, on the basis of which the behaviour of the
|
||||
algorithm is investigated for different codes and parameters.
|
||||
Finally, an improvement on proximal decoding is proposed.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|
||||
@ -252,16 +257,17 @@ return $\boldsymbol{\hat{c}}$
|
||||
\section{Implementation Details}%
|
||||
\label{sec:prox:Implementation Details}
|
||||
|
||||
The algorithm as first implemented in Python because of the fast development
|
||||
process and straightforward debugging.
|
||||
They have subsequently been reimplemented in C++ using the Eigen%
|
||||
The algorithm was first implemented in Python because of the fast development
|
||||
process and straightforward debugging ability.
|
||||
It was subsequently reimplemented in C++ using the Eigen%
|
||||
\footnote{\url{https://eigen.tuxfamily.org}}
|
||||
linear algebra library to achieve higher performance.
|
||||
The focus has been set on a fast implementation, sometimes at the expense of
|
||||
memory usage.
|
||||
The evaluation of the simulation results has been wholly realized in Python.
|
||||
|
||||
The gradient of the code-constraint polynomial is given by \cite[Sec. 2.3]{proximal_paper}%
|
||||
The gradient of the code-constraint polynomial \cite[Sec. 2.3]{proximal_paper}
|
||||
is given by%
|
||||
%
|
||||
\begin{align*}
|
||||
\nabla h\left( \boldsymbol{x} \right) &= \begin{bmatrix}
|
||||
@ -275,9 +281,10 @@ The gradient of the code-constraint polynomial is given by \cite[Sec. 2.3]{proxi
|
||||
- \prod_{i\in N_c\left( j \right) } x_i \right)
|
||||
.\end{align*}
|
||||
%
|
||||
Evidently, the products
|
||||
$\prod_{i\in N_c\left( j \right) } x_i,\hspace{1mm}\forall i\in \mathcal{J}$
|
||||
can be precomputed, as they are the same for all components $x_k$ of $\boldsymbol{x}$.
|
||||
Since the products
|
||||
$\prod_{i\in N_c\left( j \right) } x_i,\hspace{2mm}j\in \mathcal{J}$
|
||||
are the same for all components $x_k$ of $\boldsymbol{x}$, they can be
|
||||
precomputed.
|
||||
Defining%
|
||||
%
|
||||
\begin{align*}
|
||||
@ -315,11 +322,452 @@ $[-\eta, \eta]$ individually.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|
||||
\section{Results}%
|
||||
\label{sec:prox:Results}
|
||||
\section{Simulation Results}%
|
||||
\label{sec:prox:Simulation Results}
|
||||
|
||||
All simulation results presented hereafter are based on Monte Carlo
|
||||
simulations.
|
||||
The \ac{BER} and \ac{FER} curves in particular have been generated by
|
||||
producing at least 100 frame-errors for each data point, unless otherwise
|
||||
stated.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
Figure \ref{fig:prox:results} shows a comparison of the decoding performance
|
||||
of the proximal decoding algorithm as presented by Wadayama et al. in
|
||||
\cite{proximal_paper} and the implementation realized for this work.
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{figure}[H]
|
||||
\centering
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\begin{axis}[grid=both, grid style={line width=.1pt},
|
||||
xlabel={$E_b / N_0$ (dB)}, ylabel={BER},
|
||||
ymode=log,
|
||||
legend style={at={(0.5,-0.55)},anchor=south},
|
||||
width=0.75\textwidth,
|
||||
height=0.5625\textwidth,
|
||||
ymax=1.2, ymin=0.8e-4,
|
||||
xtick={1, 2, ..., 5},
|
||||
xmin=0.9, xmax=5.6,
|
||||
legend columns=2,]
|
||||
|
||||
\addplot [ForestGreen, mark=*, line width=1pt]
|
||||
table [x=SNR, y=gamma_0_15, col sep=comma] {res/proximal/ber_paper.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.15$ (Wadayama et al.)}
|
||||
\addplot [ForestGreen, mark=triangle, dashed, line width=1pt]
|
||||
table [x=SNR, y=BER, col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.15},
|
||||
discard if gt={SNR}{5.5},]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.15$ (Own results)}
|
||||
|
||||
\addplot [NavyBlue, mark=*, line width=1pt]
|
||||
table [x=SNR, y=gamma_0_01, col sep=comma] {res/proximal/ber_paper.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.01$ (Wadayama et al.)}
|
||||
\addplot [NavyBlue, mark=triangle, dashed, line width=1pt]
|
||||
table [x=SNR, y=BER, col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.01},
|
||||
discard if gt={SNR}{5.5},]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.01$ (Own results)}
|
||||
|
||||
\addplot [RedOrange, mark=*, line width=1pt]
|
||||
table [x=SNR, y=gamma_0_05, col sep=comma] {res/proximal/ber_paper.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.05$ (Wadayama et al.)}
|
||||
\addplot [RedOrange, mark=triangle, dashed, line width=1pt]
|
||||
table [x=SNR, y=BER, col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.05},
|
||||
discard if gt={SNR}{5.5},]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.05$ (Own results)}
|
||||
|
||||
\addplot [RoyalPurple, mark=*, line width=1pt]
|
||||
table [x=SNR, y=BP, col sep=comma] {res/proximal/ber_paper.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{BP (Wadayama et al.)}
|
||||
\end{axis}
|
||||
\end{tikzpicture}
|
||||
|
||||
\caption{Simulation results\protect\footnotemark{} for $\omega = 0.05, K=100$}
|
||||
\label{fig:prox:results}
|
||||
\end{figure}
|
||||
%
|
||||
\footnotetext{(3,6) regular LDPC code with n = 204, k = 102 \cite[204.33.484]{mackay_enc}}%
|
||||
%
|
||||
|
||||
Looking at the graph in figure \ref{fig:prox:results} one might notice that for
|
||||
a moderately chosen value of $\gamma$ ($\gamma = 0.05$) the decoding
|
||||
performance is better than for low ($\gamma = 0.01$) or high
|
||||
($\gamma = 0.15$) values.
|
||||
The question arises if there is some optimal value maximazing the decoding
|
||||
performance, especially since the decoding performance seems to dramatically
|
||||
depend on $\gamma$.
|
||||
To better understand how $\gamma$ and the decoding performance are
|
||||
related, figure \ref{fig:prox:results} was recreated, but with a considerably
|
||||
larger selection of values for $\gamma$ (figure \ref{fig:prox:results_3d}).%
|
||||
%
|
||||
\begin{figure}[H]
|
||||
\centering
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{tikzpicture}
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{axis}[view={75}{30},
|
||||
zmode=log,
|
||||
xlabel={$E_b / N_0$ (dB)},
|
||||
ylabel={$\gamma$},
|
||||
zlabel={BER},
|
||||
legend pos=outer north east,
|
||||
%legend style={at={(0.5,-0.55)},anchor=south},
|
||||
ytick={0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15},
|
||||
width=0.6\textwidth,
|
||||
height=0.45\textwidth,]
|
||||
|
||||
\addplot3[surf,
|
||||
mesh/rows=17, mesh/cols=14,
|
||||
colormap/viridis] table [col sep=comma,
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = \left[ 0\text{:}0.01\text{:}0.16 \right] $}
|
||||
\addplot3[NavyBlue, line width=1.5] table [col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.01},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.01$}
|
||||
\addplot3[RedOrange, line width=1.5] table [col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.05},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.05$}
|
||||
\addplot3[ForestGreen, line width=1.5] table [col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.15},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.15$}
|
||||
\end{axis}
|
||||
\end{tikzpicture}
|
||||
|
||||
\caption{BER\protect\footnotemark{} for $\omega = 0.05, K=100$}
|
||||
\label{fig:prox:results_3d}
|
||||
\end{figure}%
|
||||
%
|
||||
\footnotetext{(3,6) regular LDPC code with n = 204, k = 102 \cite[\text{204.33.484}]{mackay_enc}}%
|
||||
%
|
||||
\noindent Evidently, while the performance does depend on the value of
|
||||
$\gamma$, there is no single optimal value offering optimal performance, but
|
||||
rather a certain interval in which the performance stays largely the same.
|
||||
When examining a number of different codes (figure
|
||||
\ref{fig:prox:results_3d_multiple}), it is apparent that while the exact
|
||||
landscape of the graph depends on the code, the general behaviour is the same
|
||||
in each case.
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{figure}[H]
|
||||
\centering
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{subfigure}[c]{0.48\textwidth}
|
||||
\centering
|
||||
\begin{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\begin{axis}[view={75}{30},
|
||||
zmode=log,
|
||||
xlabel={$E_b / N_0$ (dB)},
|
||||
ylabel={$\gamma$},
|
||||
zlabel={BER},
|
||||
width=\textwidth,
|
||||
height=0.75\textwidth,]
|
||||
\addplot3[surf,
|
||||
mesh/rows=17, mesh/cols=10,
|
||||
colormap/viridis] table [col sep=comma,
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_963965.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[RedOrange, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.05},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_963965.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[NavyBlue, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.01},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_963965.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[ForestGreen, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.15},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_963965.csv};
|
||||
\end{axis}
|
||||
\end{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\caption{$\left( 3, 6 \right)$-regular LDPC code with $n=96, k=48$
|
||||
\cite[\text{96.3.965}]{mackay_enc}}
|
||||
\end{subfigure}%
|
||||
\hfill
|
||||
\begin{subfigure}[c]{0.48\textwidth}
|
||||
\centering
|
||||
\begin{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\begin{axis}[view={75}{30},
|
||||
zmode=log,
|
||||
xlabel={$E_b / N_0$ (dB)},
|
||||
ylabel={$\gamma$},
|
||||
zlabel={BER},
|
||||
width=\textwidth,
|
||||
height=0.75\textwidth,]
|
||||
\addplot3[surf,
|
||||
mesh/rows=17, mesh/cols=10,
|
||||
colormap/viridis] table [col sep=comma,
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_bch_31_26.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[RedOrange, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.05},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_bch_31_26.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[NavyBlue, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.01},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_bch_31_26.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[ForestGreen, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.15},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_bch_31_26.csv};
|
||||
\end{axis}
|
||||
\end{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\caption{BCH code with $n=31, k=26$\\[2\baselineskip]}
|
||||
\end{subfigure}
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{subfigure}[c]{0.48\textwidth}
|
||||
\centering
|
||||
\begin{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\begin{axis}[view={75}{30},
|
||||
zmode=log,
|
||||
xlabel={$E_b/N_0$ (dB)},
|
||||
ylabel={$\gamma$},
|
||||
zlabel={BER},
|
||||
width=\textwidth,
|
||||
height=0.75\textwidth,]
|
||||
\addplot3[surf,
|
||||
mesh/rows=17, mesh/cols=14,
|
||||
colormap/viridis] table [col sep=comma,
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[RedOrange, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.05},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[NavyBlue, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.01},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[ForestGreen, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.15},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv};
|
||||
\end{axis}
|
||||
\end{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\caption{$\left( 3, 6 \right)$-regular LDPC code with $n=204, k=102$
|
||||
\cite[\text{204.33.484}]{mackay_enc}}
|
||||
\end{subfigure}%
|
||||
\hfill
|
||||
\begin{subfigure}[c]{0.48\textwidth}
|
||||
\centering
|
||||
\begin{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\begin{axis}[view={75}{30},
|
||||
zmode=log,
|
||||
xlabel={$E_b / N_0$ (dB)},
|
||||
ylabel={$\gamma$},
|
||||
zlabel={BER},
|
||||
width=\textwidth,
|
||||
height=0.75\textwidth,]
|
||||
\addplot3[surf,
|
||||
mesh/rows=17, mesh/cols=10,
|
||||
colormap/viridis] table [col sep=comma,
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20455187.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[RedOrange, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.05},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20455187.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[NavyBlue, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.01},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20455187.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[ForestGreen, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.15},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20455187.csv};
|
||||
\end{axis}
|
||||
\end{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\caption{$\left( 5, 10 \right)$-regular LDPC code with $n=204, k=102$
|
||||
\cite[\text{204.55.187}]{mackay_enc}}
|
||||
\end{subfigure}%
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{subfigure}[c]{0.48\textwidth}
|
||||
\centering
|
||||
\begin{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\begin{axis}[view={75}{30},
|
||||
zmode=log,
|
||||
xlabel={$E_b / N_0$ (dB)},
|
||||
ylabel={$\gamma$},
|
||||
zlabel={BER},
|
||||
width=\textwidth,
|
||||
height=0.75\textwidth,]
|
||||
\addplot3[surf,
|
||||
mesh/rows=17, mesh/cols=10,
|
||||
colormap/viridis] table [col sep=comma,
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_40833844.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[RedOrange, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.05},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_40833844.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[NavyBlue, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.01},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_40833844.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[ForestGreen, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.15},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_40833844.csv};
|
||||
\end{axis}
|
||||
\end{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\caption{$\left( 3, 6 \right)$-regular LDPC code with $n=408, k=204$
|
||||
\cite[\text{408.33.844}]{mackay_enc}}
|
||||
\end{subfigure}%
|
||||
\hfill
|
||||
\begin{subfigure}[c]{0.48\textwidth}
|
||||
\centering
|
||||
\begin{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\begin{axis}[view={75}{30},
|
||||
zmode=log,
|
||||
xlabel={$E_b / N_0$ (dB)},
|
||||
ylabel={$\gamma$},
|
||||
zlabel={BER},
|
||||
width=\textwidth,
|
||||
height=0.75\textwidth,]
|
||||
\addplot3[surf,
|
||||
mesh/rows=17, mesh/cols=10,
|
||||
colormap/viridis] table [col sep=comma,
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_pegreg252x504.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[RedOrange, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.05},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_pegreg252x504.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[NavyBlue, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.01},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_pegreg252x504.csv};
|
||||
\addplot3[ForestGreen, line width=1.5] table[col sep=comma,
|
||||
discard if not={gamma}{0.15},
|
||||
x=SNR, y=gamma, z=BER]
|
||||
{res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_pegreg252x504.csv};
|
||||
\end{axis}
|
||||
\end{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\caption{LDPC code (Progressive Edge Growth Construction) with $n=504, k=252$
|
||||
\cite[\text{PEGReg252x504}]{mackay_enc}}
|
||||
\end{subfigure}%
|
||||
|
||||
\vspace{1cm}
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{subfigure}[c]{\textwidth}
|
||||
\centering
|
||||
\begin{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\begin{axis}[hide axis,
|
||||
xmin=10, xmax=50,
|
||||
ymin=0, ymax=0.4,
|
||||
legend style={draw=white!15!black,legend cell align=left}]
|
||||
\addlegendimage{surf, colormap/viridis}
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = \left[ 0\text{ : }0.01\text{ : }0.16 \right] $};
|
||||
\addlegendimage{NavyBlue, line width=1.5pt}
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.01$};
|
||||
\addlegendimage{RedOrange, line width=1.5pt}
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.05$};
|
||||
\addlegendimage{ForestGreen, line width=1.5pt}
|
||||
\addlegendentry{$\gamma = 0.15$};
|
||||
\end{axis}
|
||||
\end{tikzpicture}
|
||||
\end{subfigure}
|
||||
|
||||
\caption{BER for $\omega = 0.05, K=100$ (different codes)}
|
||||
\label{fig:prox:results_3d_multiple}
|
||||
\end{figure}
|
||||
|
||||
A similar analysis was performed to determine the optimal values for the other
|
||||
parameters, $\omega$, $K$ and $\eta$.
|
||||
|
||||
TODO
|
||||
|
||||
Until now, only the \ac{BER} has been considered to assess the decoding
|
||||
performance.
|
||||
The \ac{FER}, however, shows considerably worse performance, as can be seen in
|
||||
figure \ref{TODO}.
|
||||
One possible explanation might be found in the structure of the proxmal
|
||||
decoding algorithm \ref{TODO} itself.
|
||||
As it comprises two separate steps, one responsible for addressing the
|
||||
likelihood and one for addressing the constraints imposed by the parity-check
|
||||
matrix, the algorithm could tend to gravitate toward the correct codeword
|
||||
but then get stuck in a local minimum introduced by the code-constraint
|
||||
polynomial.
|
||||
This would yield fewer bit-errors, while still producing a frame error.
|
||||
This course of thought will be picked up in section
|
||||
\ref{sec:prox:Improved Implementation} to try to improve the algorithm.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item Introduction
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item asdf
|
||||
\item ghjk
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
\item Reconstruction of results from paper
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item asdf
|
||||
\item ghjk
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
\item Choice of parameters, in particular gamma
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item Introduction (``Looking at these results, the question arises \ldots'')
|
||||
\item Different gammas simulated for same code as in paper
|
||||
\item
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
\item The FER problem
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item Intro (``\acs{FER} not as good as the \acs{BER} would have one assume'')
|
||||
\item Possible explanation
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
\item Computational performance
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item Theoretical analysis
|
||||
\item Simulation results to substantiate theoretical analysis
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
\item Conclusion
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item Choice of $\gamma$ code-dependant but decoding performance largely unaffected
|
||||
by small variations
|
||||
\item Number of iterations independent of \ac{SNR}
|
||||
\item $\mathcal{O}\left( n \right)$ time complexity, implementation heavily
|
||||
optimizable
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|
||||
\section{Improved Implementation}%
|
||||
\label{sec:prox:Improved Implementation}
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item Improvement using ``ML-on-List''
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item Attach to FER problem
|
||||
\item
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
\item Decoding performance and comparison with standard proximal decoding
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item asdf
|
||||
\item ghjk
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
\item Computational performance and comparison with standard proximal decoding
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item asdf
|
||||
\item ghjk
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
\item Conclusion
|
||||
\begin{itemize}
|
||||
\item Summary
|
||||
\item Up to $\SI{1}{dB}$ gain possible
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
\end{itemize}
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
239
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv
Normal file
239
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20433484.csv
Normal file
@ -0,0 +1,239 @@
|
||||
SNR,gamma,BER,FER,DFR,num_iterations
|
||||
1.0,0.0,0.13016889924286545,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.0,0.11390992040380508,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.0,0.10430013589594253,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.0,0.09017666472529606,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.0,0.08182877111240536,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.0,0.06887012230634829,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.0,0.057173364395263056,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.0,0.04610755193166376,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.0,0.0,0.03601242477188896,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.5,0.0,0.03195886197616302,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
6.0,0.0,0.02397592700446515,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
6.5,0.0,0.017445213379469436,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
7.0,0.0,0.01270053475935829,0.9181818181818182,0.4786729857819905,110.0
|
||||
7.5,0.0,0.007798573975044563,0.7651515151515151,0.4334763948497854,132.0
|
||||
1.0,0.01,0.09410794020578528,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.01,0.06997308727412534,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.0,0.01,0.05644393679802018,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
2.5,0.01,0.03820780648708082,0.9439252336448598,0.4855769230769231,107.0
|
||||
3.0,0.01,0.025490196078431372,0.9181818181818182,0.4786729857819905,110.0
|
||||
3.5,0.01,0.014961954931226222,0.753731343283582,0.4297872340425532,134.0
|
||||
4.0,0.01,0.007832183152590644,0.5642458100558659,0.3607142857142857,179.0
|
||||
4.5,0.01,0.003332051774958349,0.3300653594771242,0.24815724815724816,306.0
|
||||
5.0,0.01,0.0017192128650021159,0.18165467625899281,0.1537290715372907,556.0
|
||||
5.5,0.01,0.0007640035685135623,0.09777347531461762,0.0890652557319224,1033.0
|
||||
6.0,0.01,0.0002406292110111927,0.03541374474053296,0.03420250592617677,2852.0
|
||||
6.5,0.01,9.533468559837728e-05,0.013931034482758621,0.01373962726159706,7250.0
|
||||
7.0,0.01,2.8408296271432968e-05,0.004502496433666191,0.004482314827142413,22432.0
|
||||
7.5,0.01,7.857008939650586e-06,0.001395567346487592,0.0013936224524995515,72372.0
|
||||
1.0,0.02,0.09030180699730873,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
1.5,0.02,0.06522331154684095,0.9351851851851852,0.48325358851674644,108.0
|
||||
2.0,0.02,0.049919050188882895,0.926605504587156,0.48095238095238096,109.0
|
||||
2.5,0.02,0.028994576554025864,0.7163120567375887,0.41735537190082644,141.0
|
||||
3.0,0.02,0.01815435476516188,0.5872093023255814,0.36996336996337,172.0
|
||||
3.5,0.02,0.009278711484593838,0.4007936507936508,0.28611898016997167,252.0
|
||||
4.0,0.02,0.003515158519203359,0.19842829076620824,0.16557377049180327,509.0
|
||||
4.5,0.02,0.0013487523022509087,0.08395677472984206,0.07745398773006135,1203.0
|
||||
5.0,0.02,0.0004013143719026072,0.027747252747252746,0.026998128842555466,3640.0
|
||||
5.5,0.02,0.00016504731356322146,0.011449948985375808,0.011320331764178435,8821.0
|
||||
6.0,0.02,4.437431042911285e-05,0.0030375026314998044,0.0030283041496761815,33251.0
|
||||
6.5,0.02,1.2192094202770043e-05,0.000845811141258835,0.0008450963493511167,119412.0
|
||||
7.0,0.02,2.764705882352941e-06,0.000196,0.0001959615915280605,500000.0
|
||||
7.5,0.02,6.96078431372549e-07,4.8e-05,4.799769611058669e-05,500000.0
|
||||
1.0,0.03,0.09037692747001713,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
1.5,0.03,0.06437619295505813,0.8938053097345132,0.4719626168224299,113.0
|
||||
2.0,0.03,0.04964273845131273,0.8559322033898306,0.4611872146118721,118.0
|
||||
2.5,0.03,0.026193913148081317,0.6196319018404908,0.38257575757575757,163.0
|
||||
3.0,0.03,0.01603641456582633,0.48095238095238096,0.3247588424437299,210.0
|
||||
3.5,0.03,0.007452113793494276,0.29190751445086704,0.22595078299776286,346.0
|
||||
4.0,0.03,0.0028573605608046325,0.13082901554404144,0.1156930126002291,772.0
|
||||
4.5,0.03,0.0010247036667774454,0.05706214689265537,0.053981827899518976,1770.0
|
||||
5.0,0.03,0.0003044266400985235,0.017819336626676077,0.01750736696134512,5668.0
|
||||
5.5,0.03,0.00012169749196725593,0.007310364794441228,0.007257311202126895,13816.0
|
||||
6.0,0.03,3.56236823804658e-05,0.0020911406033251208,0.002086776859504132,48299.0
|
||||
6.5,0.03,1.0374588367264038e-05,0.0006638447786307709,0.0006634043810962593,152144.0
|
||||
7.0,0.03,2.3627450980392157e-06,0.000152,0.0001519768995112743,500000.0
|
||||
7.5,0.03,5.196078431372548e-07,3.4e-05,3.3998844039302665e-05,500000.0
|
||||
1.0,0.04,0.09207362190159082,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
1.5,0.04,0.06675191815856778,0.8782608695652174,0.4675925925925926,115.0
|
||||
2.0,0.04,0.04750233426704015,0.8015873015873016,0.44493392070484583,126.0
|
||||
2.5,0.04,0.026018099547511313,0.5976331360946746,0.37407407407407406,169.0
|
||||
3.0,0.04,0.012881896944824441,0.39147286821705424,0.28133704735376047,258.0
|
||||
3.5,0.04,0.0065840061514802,0.24754901960784315,0.19842829076620824,408.0
|
||||
4.0,0.04,0.0026100649280614337,0.1111111111111111,0.1,909.0
|
||||
4.5,0.04,0.0009278379283402166,0.04791271347248577,0.045722046174739704,2108.0
|
||||
5.0,0.04,0.0002976899261728983,0.016356275303643725,0.016093052899936264,6175.0
|
||||
5.5,0.04,0.00011358050437191844,0.006394023803494555,0.0063534000125809904,15796.0
|
||||
6.0,0.04,4.008014206588538e-05,0.0023460546793338134,0.0023405635891731555,43051.0
|
||||
6.5,0.04,1.0293767220940665e-05,0.0006446589052287582,0.000644243587862706,156672.0
|
||||
7.0,0.04,2.450980392156863e-06,0.000154,0.00015397628765170164,500000.0
|
||||
7.5,0.04,6.176470588235294e-07,4e-05,3.999840006399744e-05,500000.0
|
||||
1.0,0.05,0.0947558268590455,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
1.5,0.05,0.06581415174765558,0.8782608695652174,0.4675925925925926,115.0
|
||||
2.0,0.05,0.047244094488188976,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
2.5,0.05,0.02558940242763772,0.6011904761904762,0.3754646840148699,168.0
|
||||
3.0,0.05,0.012649629140045532,0.3782771535580524,0.27445652173913043,267.0
|
||||
3.5,0.05,0.00588833094213295,0.20528455284552846,0.1703204047217538,492.0
|
||||
4.0,0.05,0.002538604818842757,0.10316649642492338,0.09351851851851851,979.0
|
||||
4.5,0.05,0.0009202565784678184,0.046933085501858735,0.044829116733244564,2152.0
|
||||
5.0,0.05,0.0002940220301384533,0.01641742522756827,0.01615224692147769,6152.0
|
||||
5.5,0.05,0.00011692575119219662,0.006564409203171715,0.006521598760250533,15386.0
|
||||
6.0,0.05,3.577639534879112e-05,0.002041930331763136,0.0020377693487208456,49463.0
|
||||
6.5,0.05,1.0852103196792829e-05,0.0006775658614143013,0.0006771070767745569,149063.0
|
||||
7.0,0.05,2.3725490196078433e-06,0.00015,0.00014997750337449384,500000.0
|
||||
7.5,0.05,6.568627450980392e-07,4.2e-05,4.199823607408489e-05,500000.0
|
||||
1.0,0.06,0.0957732149463559,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
1.5,0.06,0.06699346405228758,0.8632478632478633,0.463302752293578,117.0
|
||||
2.0,0.06,0.05048633626679018,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
2.5,0.06,0.026059274284426413,0.5804597701149425,0.36727272727272725,174.0
|
||||
3.0,0.06,0.012814863773224645,0.3782771535580524,0.27445652173913043,267.0
|
||||
3.5,0.06,0.006304073735924525,0.22394678492239467,0.18297101449275363,451.0
|
||||
4.0,0.06,0.0025645685668706205,0.10401647785787847,0.09421641791044776,971.0
|
||||
4.5,0.06,0.0008676426545460951,0.04537286612758311,0.04340352385045122,2226.0
|
||||
5.0,0.06,0.0003190777623385312,0.017672790901137356,0.01736588720770289,5715.0
|
||||
5.5,0.06,0.00012802567341504216,0.00732733604178758,0.00727403673028448,13784.0
|
||||
6.0,0.06,3.7053184014162366e-05,0.0021265844106623994,0.0021220716461813217,47494.0
|
||||
6.5,0.06,1.0274078481140562e-05,0.0006473612019125999,0.00064694239650523,156018.0
|
||||
7.0,0.06,2.46078431372549e-06,0.000156,0.00015597566779582386,500000.0
|
||||
7.5,0.06,5.490196078431373e-07,3.6e-05,3.599870404665432e-05,500000.0
|
||||
1.0,0.07,0.09734554199038106,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
1.5,0.07,0.06668356997971603,0.8706896551724138,0.46543778801843316,116.0
|
||||
2.0,0.07,0.0509344362745098,0.7890625,0.4410480349344978,128.0
|
||||
2.5,0.07,0.026284651791751185,0.5804597701149425,0.36727272727272725,174.0
|
||||
3.0,0.07,0.01309025482852317,0.3782771535580524,0.27445652173913043,267.0
|
||||
3.5,0.07,0.006422119409561578,0.22696629213483147,0.184981684981685,445.0
|
||||
4.0,0.07,0.002640349738129247,0.11147902869757174,0.1002979145978153,906.0
|
||||
4.5,0.07,0.0009502336090686274,0.04931640625,0.04699860400186133,2048.0
|
||||
5.0,0.07,0.0003310118602339736,0.018090632276553824,0.01776917663617171,5583.0
|
||||
5.5,0.07,0.00011619651767974708,0.0065772336545975515,0.006534256323995601,15356.0
|
||||
6.0,0.07,3.877701447136334e-05,0.002250596073712592,0.002245542265107386,44877.0
|
||||
6.5,0.07,1.1830786200915143e-05,0.0007386712693444109,0.0007381260368478364,136732.0
|
||||
7.0,0.07,2.7549019607843135e-06,0.000172,0.00017197042108757293,500000.0
|
||||
7.5,0.07,4.901960784313725e-07,3.2e-05,3.199897603276695e-05,500000.0
|
||||
1.0,0.08,0.09487813817115631,0.9439252336448598,0.4855769230769231,107.0
|
||||
1.5,0.08,0.06786680189317106,0.8706896551724138,0.46543778801843316,116.0
|
||||
2.0,0.08,0.05188536953242836,0.7769230769230769,0.43722943722943725,130.0
|
||||
2.5,0.08,0.027359781121751026,0.5872093023255814,0.36996336996337,172.0
|
||||
3.0,0.08,0.01338979171435111,0.39299610894941633,0.28212290502793297,257.0
|
||||
3.5,0.08,0.006565126050420168,0.22544642857142858,0.18397085610200364,448.0
|
||||
4.0,0.08,0.0026592336280917596,0.11002178649237472,0.09911678115799803,918.0
|
||||
4.5,0.08,0.0010749450642325896,0.05441810344827586,0.0516096065406234,1856.0
|
||||
5.0,0.08,0.00036965605914496947,0.019479267116682738,0.01910707529322739,5185.0
|
||||
5.5,0.08,0.00012361614795691875,0.007035876001393243,0.0069867183176535695,14355.0
|
||||
6.0,0.08,4.2284025381882086e-05,0.002461073612904798,0.002455031599416626,41039.0
|
||||
6.5,0.08,1.2240792065738477e-05,0.0007551176039595078,0.0007545478316088305,133754.0
|
||||
7.0,0.08,2.715686274509804e-06,0.000172,0.00017197042108757293,500000.0
|
||||
7.5,0.08,5.588235294117647e-07,3.6e-05,3.599870404665432e-05,500000.0
|
||||
1.0,0.09,0.09762301146873843,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
1.5,0.09,0.06987444100447196,0.8859649122807017,0.4697674418604651,114.0
|
||||
2.0,0.09,0.0531496062992126,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
2.5,0.09,0.028342245989304814,0.6121212121212121,0.37969924812030076,165.0
|
||||
3.0,0.09,0.015068990559186637,0.4156378600823045,0.2936046511627907,243.0
|
||||
3.5,0.09,0.006645114942528735,0.21767241379310345,0.17876106194690267,464.0
|
||||
4.0,0.09,0.0026683622451197774,0.11197339246119734,0.10069790628115653,902.0
|
||||
4.5,0.09,0.0011544262675484394,0.059763313609467454,0.056393076493579004,1690.0
|
||||
5.0,0.09,0.000323066434669353,0.017471025774087528,0.01717103026181571,5781.0
|
||||
5.5,0.09,0.00013994339191245457,0.008122235625251308,0.008056796426292279,12435.0
|
||||
6.0,0.09,4.0161512455483895e-05,0.0023244039399797477,0.0023190136155947926,43452.0
|
||||
6.5,0.09,1.2820099459406346e-05,0.0007908542792263723,0.0007902293229847196,127710.0
|
||||
7.0,0.09,2.9901960784313724e-06,0.000188,0.00018796466264342303,500000.0
|
||||
7.5,0.09,8.431372549019608e-07,5.4e-05,5.39970841574555e-05,500000.0
|
||||
1.0,0.1,0.09863478101520982,0.9439252336448598,0.4855769230769231,107.0
|
||||
1.5,0.1,0.07107843137254902,0.9017857142857143,0.47417840375586856,112.0
|
||||
2.0,0.1,0.0548406862745098,0.7890625,0.4410480349344978,128.0
|
||||
2.5,0.1,0.030971479500891266,0.6558441558441559,0.396078431372549,154.0
|
||||
3.0,0.1,0.013721912122513238,0.3686131386861314,0.2693333333333333,274.0
|
||||
3.5,0.1,0.007117601138816182,0.23653395784543327,0.19128787878787878,427.0
|
||||
4.0,0.1,0.003256827969932857,0.1377899045020464,0.1211031175059952,733.0
|
||||
4.5,0.1,0.0010676841344484178,0.04834849210148397,0.046118721461187215,2089.0
|
||||
5.0,0.1,0.000391496273499491,0.02001585414189457,0.01962308140664465,5046.0
|
||||
5.5,0.1,0.00013110636765910645,0.007300852970941159,0.007247936849659132,13834.0
|
||||
6.0,0.1,4.6469698333988914e-05,0.0027123559900099365,0.0027050190154802077,37237.0
|
||||
6.5,0.1,1.4358482214932788e-05,0.000860006301036265,0.0008592673257218697,117441.0
|
||||
7.0,0.1,3.107843137254902e-06,0.000198,0.00019796080376085535,500000.0
|
||||
7.5,0.1,8.627450980392156e-07,5.4e-05,5.39970841574555e-05,500000.0
|
||||
1.0,0.11,0.09868059373282023,0.9439252336448598,0.4855769230769231,107.0
|
||||
1.5,0.11,0.07357317927170869,0.9017857142857143,0.47417840375586856,112.0
|
||||
2.0,0.11,0.05273321449792038,0.7651515151515151,0.4334763948497854,132.0
|
||||
2.5,0.11,0.033249484004127965,0.6644736842105263,0.39920948616600793,152.0
|
||||
3.0,0.11,0.014938457134678689,0.3686131386861314,0.2693333333333333,274.0
|
||||
3.5,0.11,0.00837662033787262,0.24105011933174225,0.19423076923076923,419.0
|
||||
4.0,0.11,0.0035059537469083863,0.13133940182054615,0.11609195402298851,769.0
|
||||
4.5,0.11,0.0011208468207017151,0.04791271347248577,0.045722046174739704,2108.0
|
||||
5.0,0.11,0.00043153577768256107,0.021019771071800208,0.02058703628210355,4805.0
|
||||
5.5,0.11,0.00015734593947451842,0.00792654214409041,0.007864206182356148,12742.0
|
||||
6.0,0.11,7.48315598845975e-05,0.004068151609135216,0.0040516688061617455,24827.0
|
||||
6.5,0.11,1.59467529479283e-05,0.0009152281274070047,0.0009143912508148041,110355.0
|
||||
7.0,0.11,5.295674329001116e-06,0.0002819433433455788,0.0002818638737026587,358228.0
|
||||
7.5,0.11,1.1176470588235294e-06,6.6e-05,6.599564428747703e-05,500000.0
|
||||
1.0,0.12,0.12740384615384615,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
1.5,0.12,0.10430283224400871,0.9351851851851852,0.48325358851674644,108.0
|
||||
2.0,0.12,0.08233632436025258,0.8559322033898306,0.4611872146118721,118.0
|
||||
2.5,0.12,0.06005809731299928,0.7481481481481481,0.4279661016949153,135.0
|
||||
3.0,0.12,0.03891090114802398,0.5233160621761658,0.3435374149659864,193.0
|
||||
3.5,0.12,0.022793232816592342,0.36462093862815886,0.2671957671957672,277.0
|
||||
4.0,0.12,0.010509303903710847,0.18397085610200364,0.15538461538461537,549.0
|
||||
4.5,0.12,0.006082062454611474,0.10390946502057613,0.09412861136999068,972.0
|
||||
5.0,0.12,0.0030410982709184117,0.04972919743968488,0.0473733583489681,2031.0
|
||||
5.5,0.12,0.0012914918514713017,0.021002287377833228,0.020370747606437156,4809.0
|
||||
6.0,0.12,0.0006120792155158086,0.010975874809823951,0.010856712888315597,9202.0
|
||||
6.5,0.12,0.0002848113322386914,0.00478650300933605,0.0047637015375907935,21101.0
|
||||
7.0,0.12,0.00015880719643403545,0.0026623787431463517,0.0026553093040986406,37936.0
|
||||
7.5,0.12,9.887878094521482e-05,0.001552818904417078,0.0015504113962912932,65043.0
|
||||
1.0,0.13,0.20258202290817318,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.13,0.1892350999805863,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.13,0.1705788084464555,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
2.5,0.13,0.16332233828110684,0.9439252336448598,0.4855769230769231,107.0
|
||||
3.0,0.13,0.13447583757912615,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
3.5,0.13,0.12821350762527234,0.7481481481481481,0.4279661016949153,135.0
|
||||
4.0,0.13,0.09359325125398997,0.5872093023255814,0.36996336996337,172.0
|
||||
4.5,0.13,0.07852299798424042,0.4719626168224299,0.32063492063492066,214.0
|
||||
5.0,0.13,0.061255361519607844,0.39453125,0.28291316526610644,256.0
|
||||
5.5,0.13,0.057405013287366226,0.36996336996337,0.2700534759358289,273.0
|
||||
6.0,0.13,0.05830388692579505,0.3568904593639576,0.2630208333333333,283.0
|
||||
6.5,0.13,0.053853009735362674,0.3531468531468531,0.26098191214470284,286.0
|
||||
7.0,0.13,0.04520697167755991,0.28055555555555556,0.21908893709327548,360.0
|
||||
7.5,0.13,0.04738082916451038,0.2961876832844575,0.22850678733031674,341.0
|
||||
1.0,0.14,0.30188312948941953,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.14,0.2989225393127548,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.14,0.2915938652688798,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.14,0.2830161476355248,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
3.0,0.14,0.26663838612368024,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
3.5,0.14,0.26035367417995237,0.9439252336448598,0.4855769230769231,107.0
|
||||
4.0,0.14,0.2349137931034483,0.8706896551724138,0.46543778801843316,116.0
|
||||
4.5,0.14,0.22372227579556414,0.8278688524590164,0.452914798206278,122.0
|
||||
5.0,0.14,0.22702965483714146,0.8347107438016529,0.45495495495495497,121.0
|
||||
5.5,0.14,0.20850433196534426,0.7829457364341085,0.4391304347826087,129.0
|
||||
6.0,0.14,0.20122549019607844,0.7214285714285714,0.4190871369294606,140.0
|
||||
6.5,0.14,0.1672268907563025,0.5771428571428572,0.36594202898550726,175.0
|
||||
7.0,0.14,0.14585645578986312,0.47641509433962265,0.3226837060702875,212.0
|
||||
7.5,0.14,0.10216795051353875,0.3005952380952381,0.2311212814645309,336.0
|
||||
1.0,0.15,0.37036497767423804,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.15,0.36036691904484563,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.15,0.35255290234905845,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.15,0.3493981751116288,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.15,0.3480392156862745,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
3.5,0.15,0.34475537787930705,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
4.0,0.15,0.34837235865219873,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
4.5,0.15,0.3258258258258258,0.9099099099099099,0.47641509433962265,111.0
|
||||
5.0,0.15,0.3237076648841355,0.9181818181818182,0.4786729857819905,110.0
|
||||
5.5,0.15,0.30232947880006705,0.8632478632478633,0.463302752293578,117.0
|
||||
6.0,0.15,0.2957248473159756,0.8278688524590164,0.452914798206278,122.0
|
||||
6.5,0.15,0.22986804784807005,0.6352201257861635,0.38846153846153847,159.0
|
||||
7.0,0.15,0.15203828566999922,0.39920948616600793,0.2853107344632768,253.0
|
||||
7.5,0.15,0.10432479443390259,0.271505376344086,0.2135306553911205,372.0
|
||||
1.0,0.16,0.40870704717530576,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.16,0.4099204038050864,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.16,0.39845251826220685,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.5,0.16,0.39511745292176276,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.16,0.4057949912638323,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.16,0.40695981362842165,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.16,0.4024842946887493,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
4.5,0.16,0.3882447209653092,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
5.0,0.16,0.4009515570934256,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
5.5,0.16,0.37219251336898396,0.9181818181818182,0.4786729857819905,110.0
|
||||
6.0,0.16,0.34126786307743434,0.8559322033898306,0.4611872146118721,118.0
|
||||
6.5,0.16,0.310105580693816,0.7769230769230769,0.43722943722943725,130.0
|
||||
7.0,0.16,0.27992238562091504,0.7013888888888888,0.4122448979591837,144.0
|
||||
7.5,0.16,0.20819364015036065,0.5233160621761658,0.3435374149659864,193.0
|
||||
|
@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"duration": 1056.983127202002,
|
||||
"name": "2d_BER_FER_DFR_20433484",
|
||||
"platform": "Linux-6.1.6-arch1-1-x86_64-with-glibc2.36",
|
||||
"omega": 0.05,
|
||||
"K": 200,
|
||||
"end_time": "2023-01-17 18:58:33.496993"
|
||||
}
|
||||
171
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20455187.csv
Normal file
171
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_20455187.csv
Normal file
@ -0,0 +1,171 @@
|
||||
SNR,gamma,BER,FER,DFR,num_iterations
|
||||
1.0,0.0,0.13041157056882158,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.0,0.11803533294505922,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.0,0.10337798485730926,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.0,0.09109881576392934,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.0,0.0828965249466123,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.0,0.0648417782954766,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.0,0.05547466511357018,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.0,0.04615608619685498,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.0,0.0,0.03751698699281693,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.5,0.0,0.028745478774033887,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
1.0,0.01,0.12682003494467095,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.01,0.10303824500097068,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.01,0.0895202741290691,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
2.5,0.01,0.06111710739341608,0.926605504587156,0.48095238095238096,109.0
|
||||
3.0,0.01,0.042294603791929994,0.8347107438016529,0.45495495495495497,121.0
|
||||
3.5,0.01,0.0196078431372549,0.5804597701149425,0.36727272727272725,174.0
|
||||
4.0,0.01,0.008482389821132214,0.3166144200626959,0.24047619047619048,319.0
|
||||
4.5,0.01,0.0031009641425631027,0.13950276243093923,0.12242424242424242,724.0
|
||||
5.0,0.01,0.000809970597599116,0.04823304680038205,0.04601366742596811,2094.0
|
||||
5.5,0.01,0.00016017610218320026,0.011786672890652352,0.011649365628604382,8569.0
|
||||
1.0,0.02,0.12759658318773054,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.02,0.10368814192343605,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
2.0,0.02,0.09073083778966132,0.9181818181818182,0.4786729857819905,110.0
|
||||
2.5,0.02,0.05997927626335087,0.8211382113821138,0.45089285714285715,123.0
|
||||
3.0,0.02,0.038327205882352944,0.63125,0.38697318007662834,160.0
|
||||
3.5,0.02,0.016095037363479593,0.3289902280130293,0.24754901960784315,307.0
|
||||
4.0,0.02,0.005628976994615761,0.14831130690161526,0.12915601023017903,681.0
|
||||
4.5,0.02,0.001486085989181294,0.04374187960155912,0.041908713692946055,2309.0
|
||||
5.0,0.02,0.0003706720496747766,0.012161348585189646,0.012015227218653344,8305.0
|
||||
5.5,0.02,4.3831770108026713e-05,0.0016662542275014435,0.0016634824428486724,60615.0
|
||||
1.0,0.03,0.12842166569598137,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.03,0.10506221719457014,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
2.0,0.03,0.09215686274509804,0.9181818181818182,0.4786729857819905,110.0
|
||||
2.5,0.03,0.059200603318250375,0.7769230769230769,0.43722943722943725,130.0
|
||||
3.0,0.03,0.039246133235903057,0.6273291925465838,0.38549618320610685,161.0
|
||||
3.5,0.03,0.01752055660974067,0.3258064516129032,0.24574209245742093,310.0
|
||||
4.0,0.03,0.006353001323228678,0.1549079754601227,0.1341301460823373,652.0
|
||||
4.5,0.03,0.0015639997257644316,0.04414335664335664,0.04227710339053997,2288.0
|
||||
5.0,0.03,0.00041049690434868236,0.012680477087256748,0.01252169600793454,7965.0
|
||||
5.5,0.03,4.623396973812682e-05,0.001707176904093844,0.0017042674181192313,59162.0
|
||||
1.0,0.04,0.13046010483401282,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.04,0.10644257703081232,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
2.0,0.04,0.09255793226381462,0.9181818181818182,0.4786729857819905,110.0
|
||||
2.5,0.04,0.061659374493599095,0.8347107438016529,0.45495495495495497,121.0
|
||||
3.0,0.04,0.037362505978000955,0.6158536585365854,0.38113207547169814,164.0
|
||||
3.5,0.04,0.017938334754191532,0.36594202898550726,0.26790450928381965,276.0
|
||||
4.0,0.04,0.006777361022169365,0.15707620528771385,0.135752688172043,643.0
|
||||
4.5,0.04,0.001880984952120383,0.05872093023255814,0.05546403075233388,1720.0
|
||||
5.0,0.04,0.00047726234453046763,0.015584014812528931,0.01534487997569128,6481.0
|
||||
5.5,0.04,5.9633434663944794e-05,0.002381176914371935,0.0023755203800832608,42416.0
|
||||
1.0,0.05,0.13012036497767424,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.05,0.10630252100840336,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
2.0,0.05,0.09390178089584458,0.926605504587156,0.48095238095238096,109.0
|
||||
2.5,0.05,0.060058669136946116,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
3.0,0.05,0.03856825749167592,0.6352201257861635,0.38846153846153847,159.0
|
||||
3.5,0.05,0.020580454403983817,0.4007936507936508,0.28611898016997167,252.0
|
||||
4.0,0.05,0.008242486183662655,0.19498069498069498,0.1631663974151858,518.0
|
||||
4.5,0.05,0.0024946180252516438,0.07492581602373888,0.06970324361628709,1348.0
|
||||
5.0,0.05,0.0006870391739773196,0.023871425194989363,0.023314866112650046,4231.0
|
||||
5.5,0.05,0.0001187199352756501,0.005033138984402253,0.005007933359777866,20067.0
|
||||
1.0,0.06,0.13963308095515434,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.06,0.12782805429864252,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
2.0,0.06,0.11363211951447245,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
2.5,0.06,0.093968837535014,0.9017857142857143,0.47417840375586856,112.0
|
||||
3.0,0.06,0.08508986928104575,0.8416666666666667,0.45701357466063347,120.0
|
||||
3.5,0.06,0.07619485294117648,0.63125,0.38697318007662834,160.0
|
||||
4.0,0.06,0.06640495181123297,0.4279661016949153,0.2997032640949555,236.0
|
||||
4.5,0.06,0.04242399206873761,0.28370786516853935,0.2210065645514223,356.0
|
||||
5.0,0.06,0.025403188216649577,0.1600633914421553,0.13797814207650272,631.0
|
||||
5.5,0.06,0.018433179723502304,0.09308755760368663,0.0851602023608769,1085.0
|
||||
1.0,0.07,0.20889147738303243,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.07,0.19986410405746458,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.07,0.19626879878164857,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
2.5,0.07,0.19612648981161093,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
3.0,0.07,0.1917420814479638,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
3.5,0.07,0.1957720588235294,0.9017857142857143,0.47417840375586856,112.0
|
||||
4.0,0.07,0.14399509803921567,0.6644736842105263,0.39920948616600793,152.0
|
||||
4.5,0.07,0.13647504456327986,0.5738636363636364,0.36462093862815886,176.0
|
||||
5.0,0.07,0.12161634565330556,0.4469026548672566,0.308868501529052,226.0
|
||||
5.5,0.07,0.07485094351220112,0.3166144200626959,0.24047619047619048,319.0
|
||||
1.0,0.08,0.2632013201320132,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.08,0.26635604736944285,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.08,0.25413302575932334,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.5,0.08,0.27674238012036495,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.08,0.26018838908112263,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
3.5,0.08,0.24689250700280113,0.9017857142857143,0.47417840375586856,112.0
|
||||
4.0,0.08,0.2452281797674822,0.8938053097345132,0.4719626168224299,113.0
|
||||
4.5,0.08,0.2685277500830841,0.8559322033898306,0.4611872146118721,118.0
|
||||
5.0,0.08,0.1766712532966403,0.5906432748538012,0.3713235294117647,171.0
|
||||
5.5,0.08,0.1536550103912533,0.46543778801843316,0.31761006289308175,217.0
|
||||
1.0,0.09,0.3060085420306737,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.09,0.30348476024072996,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.09,0.30401863715783345,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.09,0.3125121335662978,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.09,0.3019511726259131,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
3.5,0.09,0.31381975867269984,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
4.0,0.09,0.2743748875697068,0.926605504587156,0.48095238095238096,109.0
|
||||
4.5,0.09,0.26221599751011515,0.8015873015873016,0.44493392070484583,126.0
|
||||
5.0,0.09,0.2593759726112667,0.8015873015873016,0.44493392070484583,126.0
|
||||
5.5,0.09,0.25,0.7426470588235294,0.42616033755274263,136.0
|
||||
1.0,0.1,0.3504659289458358,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.1,0.34017666472529606,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.1,0.3299359347699476,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.1,0.35085420306736553,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.1,0.3425548437196661,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.1,0.3208427601809955,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
4.0,0.1,0.3398378582202112,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
4.5,0.1,0.2778876256384907,0.8487394957983193,0.4590909090909091,119.0
|
||||
5.0,0.1,0.2815638450502152,0.8211382113821138,0.45089285714285715,123.0
|
||||
5.5,0.1,0.23818592185075468,0.7266187050359713,0.42083333333333334,139.0
|
||||
1.0,0.11,0.36633663366336633,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.11,0.35774606872451953,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.11,0.3492040380508639,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.11,0.36740438749757326,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.11,0.3654144826247331,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.11,0.35391186177441275,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.11,0.36538461538461536,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
4.5,0.11,0.34916351861845657,0.926605504587156,0.48095238095238096,109.0
|
||||
5.0,0.11,0.3227124183006536,0.8859649122807017,0.4697674418604651,114.0
|
||||
5.5,0.11,0.34650468883205454,0.8782608695652174,0.4675925925925926,115.0
|
||||
1.0,0.12,0.40166957872257814,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.12,0.37919821393904096,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.12,0.3928363424577752,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.12,0.38827412152980006,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.12,0.38211026985051444,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.12,0.42176276451174527,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.12,0.38475586312956556,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
4.5,0.12,0.3806542418947777,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.0,0.12,0.41387927720107653,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
5.5,0.12,0.4516217702034085,0.9439252336448598,0.4855769230769231,107.0
|
||||
1.0,0.13,0.4370995923121724,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.13,0.45971655989128324,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.13,0.45520287322849934,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.13,0.4187051058046981,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.13,0.4418074160357212,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.13,0.4629198213939041,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.13,0.4772859638905067,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.13,0.4520750047591852,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
5.0,0.13,0.4471577621874438,0.926605504587156,0.48095238095238096,109.0
|
||||
5.5,0.13,0.4532952069716776,0.9351851851851852,0.48325358851674644,108.0
|
||||
1.0,0.14,0.49155503785672683,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.14,0.4717045233935158,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.14,0.47316055134925256,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.14,0.48786643370219374,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.14,0.4816055134925257,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.14,0.4835468841001747,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.14,0.4920889147738303,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.14,0.48755286428296807,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
5.0,0.14,0.4675124951941561,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
5.5,0.14,0.44789915966386556,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
1.0,0.15,0.484469035138808,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.15,0.503445932828577,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.15,0.4925257231605514,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.15,0.49694234129295284,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.15,0.49349640846437587,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.15,0.48306154144826247,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.15,0.4417103475053388,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.15,0.4343041138023837,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
5.0,0.15,0.3842854449472097,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
5.5,0.15,0.31829104190695884,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
1.0,0.16,0.49213744903902157,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.16,0.4996117258784702,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.16,0.48985633857503397,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.16,0.4789361289070084,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.16,0.4693263443991458,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.16,0.4420986216268686,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.16,0.40870704717530576,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.16,0.3709150326797386,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
5.0,0.16,0.27003205128205127,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
5.5,0.16,0.21101774042950514,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
|
@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"duration": 198.41980844998034,
|
||||
"name": "2d_BER_FER_DFR_20455187",
|
||||
"platform": "Linux-6.1.6-arch1-3-x86_64-with-glibc2.36",
|
||||
"omega": 0.05,
|
||||
"K": 200,
|
||||
"end_time": "2023-01-23 22:13:26.097517"
|
||||
}
|
||||
171
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_40833844.csv
Normal file
171
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_40833844.csv
Normal file
@ -0,0 +1,171 @@
|
||||
SNR,gamma,BER,FER,DFR,num_iterations
|
||||
1.0,0.0,0.1327412152980004,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.0,0.12002523781789944,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.0,0.10524655406717143,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.0,0.09148708988545913,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.0,0.07806736556008542,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.0,0.06503591535624151,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.0,0.05629974762182101,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.0,0.04416618132401475,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.0,0.0,0.03792952824694234,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.5,0.0,0.03026111434672879,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.0,0.01,0.09954377790720248,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.01,0.07544651523975927,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.01,0.05896913220733838,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.01,0.03996796738497379,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.01,0.025080906148867314,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
3.5,0.01,0.016302392516639685,0.926605504587156,0.48095238095238096,109.0
|
||||
4.0,0.01,0.00897406206577119,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
4.5,0.01,0.0034208870714061024,0.5401069518716578,0.3506944444444444,187.0
|
||||
5.0,0.01,0.0016993464052287581,0.33666666666666667,0.2518703241895262,300.0
|
||||
5.5,0.01,0.0007873385288779759,0.18330308529945555,0.1549079754601227,551.0
|
||||
1.0,0.02,0.09811201708406135,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.02,0.07202484954377791,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.02,0.05518345952242283,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.02,0.03207282913165266,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
3.0,0.02,0.017694882831181254,0.8211382113821138,0.45089285714285715,123.0
|
||||
3.5,0.02,0.009183611716291454,0.6234567901234568,0.3840304182509506,162.0
|
||||
4.0,0.02,0.0037088420273769887,0.38113207547169814,0.27595628415300544,265.0
|
||||
4.5,0.02,0.0014432168806608938,0.17089678510998307,0.14595375722543352,591.0
|
||||
5.0,0.02,0.00044169611307420494,0.059481743227326266,0.05614230127848805,1698.0
|
||||
5.5,0.02,0.00012734797835084368,0.019293218720152817,0.018928035982008994,5235.0
|
||||
1.0,0.03,0.09905843525529023,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.03,0.07076295864880605,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.03,0.05387303436225976,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.03,0.02882090336134454,0.9017857142857143,0.47417840375586856,112.0
|
||||
3.0,0.03,0.014161220043572984,0.6601307189542484,0.39763779527559057,153.0
|
||||
3.5,0.03,0.006363949088407293,0.44298245614035087,0.3069908814589666,228.0
|
||||
4.0,0.03,0.0021808322527407755,0.20240480961923848,0.16833333333333333,499.0
|
||||
4.5,0.03,0.0008810872909243142,0.1002979145978153,0.09115523465703972,1007.0
|
||||
5.0,0.03,0.0002742744843639694,0.03276029841063899,0.03172110552763819,3083.0
|
||||
5.5,0.03,8.158493387659922e-05,0.01088010341484434,0.01076300085251492,9283.0
|
||||
1.0,0.04,0.10039312754804892,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.04,0.07076295864880605,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.04,0.051965497737556564,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
2.5,0.04,0.026656943769243234,0.8347107438016529,0.45495495495495497,121.0
|
||||
3.0,0.04,0.013190730837789662,0.6121212121212121,0.37969924812030076,165.0
|
||||
3.5,0.04,0.005154908938664434,0.3594306049822064,0.2643979057591623,281.0
|
||||
4.0,0.04,0.0018190870098039216,0.1578125,0.13630229419703105,640.0
|
||||
4.5,0.04,0.0007194064807277609,0.07356154406409322,0.06852103120759837,1373.0
|
||||
5.0,0.04,0.0002228774281555953,0.02766365379348124,0.026918976545842216,3651.0
|
||||
5.5,0.04,7.447663891990073e-05,0.00993214672042482,0.009834469328140215,10169.0
|
||||
1.0,0.05,0.10167928557561638,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.05,0.07151523975927004,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.05,0.05165556788753237,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
2.5,0.05,0.0284432321315623,0.8145161290322581,0.4488888888888889,124.0
|
||||
3.0,0.05,0.012762501450284255,0.5976331360946746,0.37407407407407406,169.0
|
||||
3.5,0.05,0.004894130176032074,0.3226837060702875,0.24396135265700483,313.0
|
||||
4.0,0.05,0.0016947171575502572,0.14165497896213183,0.12407862407862408,713.0
|
||||
4.5,0.05,0.0006147052551026808,0.06461932181701856,0.060697115384615384,1563.0
|
||||
5.0,0.05,0.00019840704095501507,0.02447891420261755,0.023894014667612963,4126.0
|
||||
5.5,0.05,7.173370936898876e-05,0.00972369307788582,0.009630053394355454,10387.0
|
||||
1.0,0.06,0.10252863521646283,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.06,0.07224325373713841,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.06,0.04353715170278638,0.8859649122807017,0.4697674418604651,114.0
|
||||
2.5,0.06,0.028862745098039214,0.808,0.4469026548672566,125.0
|
||||
3.0,0.06,0.012603128683167255,0.5519125683060109,0.35563380281690143,183.0
|
||||
3.5,0.06,0.004949552636588616,0.3268608414239482,0.24634146341463414,309.0
|
||||
4.0,0.06,0.001551538046411225,0.13237221494102228,0.11689814814814815,763.0
|
||||
4.5,0.06,0.0006391740505093875,0.06702057067020571,0.06281094527363185,1507.0
|
||||
5.0,0.06,0.00020591230382173236,0.02571283095723014,0.02506825515016133,3928.0
|
||||
5.5,0.06,8.264995289216742e-05,0.01088127558715794,0.010764147927102206,9282.0
|
||||
1.0,0.07,0.10408173170258202,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.07,0.06858120606733259,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
2.0,0.07,0.042735042735042736,0.8632478632478633,0.463302752293578,117.0
|
||||
2.5,0.07,0.02873629766867377,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
3.0,0.07,0.013418079096045197,0.5706214689265536,0.36330935251798563,177.0
|
||||
3.5,0.07,0.0048166418466120626,0.31962025316455694,0.2422062350119904,316.0
|
||||
4.0,0.07,0.0017955261763311298,0.14366998577524892,0.1256218905472637,703.0
|
||||
4.5,0.07,0.0006143042458713765,0.06424936386768448,0.06037059175134489,1572.0
|
||||
5.0,0.07,0.00020633253301320528,0.02576530612244898,0.02511812981845312,3920.0
|
||||
5.5,0.07,7.564137897978503e-05,0.010287227541250764,0.01018247807238633,9818.0
|
||||
1.0,0.08,0.09738400310619297,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.08,0.06936736958934517,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
2.0,0.08,0.043842968221771465,0.8706896551724138,0.46543778801843316,116.0
|
||||
2.5,0.08,0.029508259996912152,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
3.0,0.08,0.01276152919268266,0.5642458100558659,0.3607142857142857,179.0
|
||||
3.5,0.08,0.0051383897610491145,0.3247588424437299,0.24514563106796117,311.0
|
||||
4.0,0.08,0.0018155410312273058,0.14387464387464388,0.12577833125778332,702.0
|
||||
4.5,0.08,0.0006484158993480963,0.06532988357050452,0.06132361870066788,1546.0
|
||||
5.0,0.08,0.00023576161075556558,0.027678816114003836,0.026933333333333333,3649.0
|
||||
5.5,0.08,7.741265230371984e-05,0.010390946502057612,0.01028408512371449,9720.0
|
||||
1.0,0.09,0.09808774995146574,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.09,0.07047724750277469,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
2.0,0.09,0.04428815004262575,0.8782608695652174,0.4675925925925926,115.0
|
||||
2.5,0.09,0.0311453849832616,0.8211382113821138,0.45089285714285715,123.0
|
||||
3.0,0.09,0.013280893752849977,0.5872093023255814,0.36996336996337,172.0
|
||||
3.5,0.09,0.00498517308157831,0.3117283950617284,0.2376470588235294,324.0
|
||||
4.0,0.09,0.0018756808278867102,0.14027777777777778,0.12302070645554203,720.0
|
||||
4.5,0.09,0.0007000367902546703,0.07018763029881862,0.06558441558441558,1439.0
|
||||
5.0,0.09,0.00022185312925494433,0.027289921642799243,0.026564965807469754,3701.0
|
||||
5.5,0.09,7.948846591390057e-05,0.010634937348636412,0.010523025630339654,9497.0
|
||||
1.0,0.1,0.0993739079790332,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.1,0.0714829621168856,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
2.0,0.1,0.044159905341446926,0.8706896551724138,0.46543778801843316,116.0
|
||||
2.5,0.1,0.03134167052647831,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
3.0,0.1,0.012507992327365729,0.5489130434782609,0.3543859649122807,184.0
|
||||
3.5,0.1,0.004879543280726925,0.3079268292682927,0.23543123543123542,328.0
|
||||
4.0,0.1,0.001969979911156382,0.14574314574314573,0.12720403022670027,693.0
|
||||
4.5,0.1,0.0006428801028608164,0.06368221941992434,0.05986959098992294,1586.0
|
||||
5.0,0.1,0.00026748252878467575,0.033300362677217275,0.032227185705169116,3033.0
|
||||
5.5,0.1,8.931155488025469e-05,0.011646678966789668,0.01151259546335347,8672.0
|
||||
1.0,0.11,0.10090273733255678,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.11,0.07425999245852187,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
2.0,0.11,0.047407120743034055,0.8859649122807017,0.4697674418604651,114.0
|
||||
2.5,0.11,0.032392156862745096,0.808,0.4469026548672566,125.0
|
||||
3.0,0.11,0.01542016806722689,0.5771428571428572,0.36594202898550726,175.0
|
||||
3.5,0.11,0.005979753464903877,0.3289902280130293,0.24754901960784315,307.0
|
||||
4.0,0.11,0.002810983548348917,0.20321931589537223,0.1688963210702341,497.0
|
||||
4.5,0.11,0.0009884699760216316,0.08759757155247182,0.08054226475279107,1153.0
|
||||
5.0,0.11,0.00030246450404546277,0.029961435775734204,0.029089861751152073,3371.0
|
||||
5.5,0.11,0.00011746755783627398,0.013597199784598816,0.013414796121662903,7428.0
|
||||
1.0,0.12,0.11767132595612502,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.12,0.08668219763152786,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.12,0.06310160427807486,0.9181818181818182,0.4786729857819905,110.0
|
||||
2.5,0.12,0.04702949555890732,0.8632478632478633,0.463302752293578,117.0
|
||||
3.0,0.12,0.030303030303030304,0.7062937062937062,0.4139344262295082,143.0
|
||||
3.5,0.12,0.018493761140819964,0.5401069518716578,0.3506944444444444,187.0
|
||||
4.0,0.12,0.009836492736629536,0.33554817275747506,0.2512437810945274,301.0
|
||||
4.5,0.12,0.005295641572691252,0.17443868739205526,0.14852941176470588,579.0
|
||||
5.0,0.12,0.003074199765376236,0.10790598290598291,0.09739633558341369,936.0
|
||||
5.5,0.12,0.0016318163822383364,0.0536663124335813,0.050932929904185575,1882.0
|
||||
1.0,0.13,0.18137254901960784,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.13,0.16142496602601436,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.13,0.13886485966935794,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.5,0.13,0.13096971461852067,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.13,0.11723856209150327,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
3.5,0.13,0.10651056539120503,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
4.0,0.13,0.10336538461538461,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
4.5,0.13,0.10147058823529412,0.9181818181818182,0.4786729857819905,110.0
|
||||
5.0,0.13,0.08615505025539627,0.8487394957983193,0.4590909090909091,119.0
|
||||
5.5,0.13,0.09505347593582887,0.9181818181818182,0.4786729857819905,110.0
|
||||
1.0,0.14,0.2747524752475248,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.14,0.26174529217627646,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.14,0.25575131042516014,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.14,0.24847117064647642,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.14,0.24291399728208116,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.14,0.2360221316249272,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.14,0.23315860997864493,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.14,0.22270280661284123,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
5.0,0.14,0.22541739468064453,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.5,0.14,0.22677517608985343,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
1.0,0.15,0.34425354300135896,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.15,0.3462677150067948,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.15,0.33083381867598527,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.15,0.3319258396427878,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.15,0.32052028732284993,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.15,0.319889341875364,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.15,0.32469423412929527,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.15,0.31624927198602215,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.0,0.15,0.326465734808775,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.5,0.15,0.32002114571318724,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
1.0,0.16,0.4066928751698699,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.16,0.400237817899437,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.16,0.3921083284799068,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.16,0.3986847214133178,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.16,0.3947777130654242,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.16,0.39315181518151815,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.16,0.3928606095903708,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.16,0.3902397592700447,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.0,0.16,0.3845855173752669,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.5,0.16,0.39101630751310423,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
|
@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"duration": 560.566807908006,
|
||||
"name": "2d_BER_FER_DFR_40833844",
|
||||
"platform": "Linux-6.1.6-arch1-3-x86_64-with-glibc2.36",
|
||||
"omega": 0.05,
|
||||
"K": 200,
|
||||
"end_time": "2023-01-23 21:30:08.407054"
|
||||
}
|
||||
171
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_963965.csv
Normal file
171
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_963965.csv
Normal file
@ -0,0 +1,171 @@
|
||||
SNR,gamma,BER,FER,DFR,num_iterations
|
||||
1.0,0.0,0.1346947194719472,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.0,0.11117986798679869,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.0,0.09674092409240924,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.0,0.08745874587458746,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.0,0.07466996699669967,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.0,0.06775990099009901,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.0,0.06012788778877888,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.0,0.0445995145631068,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
5.0,0.0,0.03786057692307692,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
5.5,0.0,0.0294811320754717,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
1.0,0.01,0.10416666666666667,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
1.5,0.01,0.07615959119496855,0.9528301886792453,0.4854368932038835,106.0
|
||||
2.0,0.01,0.04875341530054645,0.8278688524590164,0.452914798206278,122.0
|
||||
2.5,0.01,0.041901629072681704,0.7593984962406015,0.43162393162393164,133.0
|
||||
3.0,0.01,0.024725274725274724,0.554945054945055,0.3568904593639576,182.0
|
||||
3.5,0.01,0.012889105058365758,0.39299610894941633,0.28212290502793297,257.0
|
||||
4.0,0.01,0.008898305084745763,0.3423728813559322,0.255050505050505,295.0
|
||||
4.5,0.01,0.004365257793764988,0.18165467625899281,0.1537290715372907,556.0
|
||||
5.0,0.01,0.0024319903581267216,0.10433884297520661,0.09448082319925163,968.0
|
||||
5.5,0.01,0.0008933129147524247,0.0515569167942828,0.04902912621359223,1959.0
|
||||
1.0,0.02,0.10212053571428571,0.9017857142857143,0.47417840375586856,112.0
|
||||
1.5,0.02,0.06855413105413105,0.8632478632478633,0.463302752293578,117.0
|
||||
2.0,0.02,0.04114906832298137,0.6273291925465838,0.38549618320610685,161.0
|
||||
2.5,0.02,0.031361408199643497,0.5401069518716578,0.3506944444444444,187.0
|
||||
3.0,0.02,0.017597087378640776,0.3268608414239482,0.24449877750611246,309.0
|
||||
3.5,0.02,0.010438413361169102,0.21085594989561587,0.17271157167530224,479.0
|
||||
4.0,0.02,0.005260028949545079,0.12531017369727046,0.1113561190738699,806.0
|
||||
4.5,0.02,0.0022165770073719867,0.06037059175134489,0.05640157924421884,1673.0
|
||||
5.0,0.02,0.0007308728050759923,0.022355024347056218,0.021442495126705652,4518.0
|
||||
5.5,0.02,0.00026402608673456365,0.007734129718967761,0.007523939808481532,13059.0
|
||||
1.0,0.03,0.10360863095238096,0.9017857142857143,0.47417840375586856,112.0
|
||||
1.5,0.03,0.06602690288713911,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
2.0,0.03,0.04184222846441948,0.5674157303370787,0.3597122302158273,178.0
|
||||
2.5,0.03,0.030358483483483484,0.45495495495495497,0.3126934984520124,222.0
|
||||
3.0,0.03,0.01581892730496454,0.26861702127659576,0.21008403361344538,376.0
|
||||
3.5,0.03,0.010331805838424983,0.20570264765784113,0.16779661016949152,491.0
|
||||
4.0,0.03,0.004622958693563881,0.09702209414024976,0.08844133099824869,1041.0
|
||||
4.5,0.03,0.0019200598365440747,0.044220665499124345,0.04154427192614352,2284.0
|
||||
5.0,0.03,0.0007336201289101768,0.017917331914138725,0.017259414225941423,5637.0
|
||||
5.5,0.03,0.00024454967103918927,0.006191001593723182,0.005850091407678245,16314.0
|
||||
1.0,0.04,0.10526315789473684,0.8859649122807017,0.4672897196261682,114.0
|
||||
1.5,0.04,0.06615360696517412,0.753731343283582,0.42735042735042733,134.0
|
||||
2.0,0.04,0.040803108808290155,0.5233160621761658,0.3412969283276451,193.0
|
||||
2.5,0.04,0.028255208333333334,0.42083333333333334,0.2961876832844575,240.0
|
||||
3.0,0.04,0.015997942386831276,0.24938271604938272,0.19960474308300397,405.0
|
||||
3.5,0.04,0.009956813819577736,0.19385796545105566,0.1596774193548387,521.0
|
||||
4.0,0.04,0.004163225984035232,0.08340214698596202,0.07627765064836003,1211.0
|
||||
4.5,0.04,0.0022122524752475245,0.05,0.04716981132075472,2020.0
|
||||
5.0,0.04,0.0007477800841838206,0.017471025774087528,0.01683673469387755,5781.0
|
||||
5.5,0.04,0.00023787331546856188,0.005883723639753,0.005561348627042058,17166.0
|
||||
1.0,0.05,0.10697463768115942,0.8782608695652174,0.46511627906976744,115.0
|
||||
1.5,0.05,0.06957697201017812,0.7709923664122137,0.4329004329004329,131.0
|
||||
2.0,0.05,0.041161003236245955,0.49029126213592233,0.32679738562091504,206.0
|
||||
2.5,0.05,0.030123873873873875,0.45495495495495497,0.3105590062111801,222.0
|
||||
3.0,0.05,0.01552030988274707,0.2537688442211055,0.20240480961923848,398.0
|
||||
3.5,0.05,0.010208333333333333,0.18363636363636363,0.15384615384615385,550.0
|
||||
4.0,0.05,0.004118015012510425,0.08423686405337781,0.07627118644067797,1199.0
|
||||
4.5,0.05,0.002075984714873604,0.0445326278659612,0.04182509505703422,2268.0
|
||||
5.0,0.05,0.0006656446667742456,0.01629820881071486,0.015724269377382465,6197.0
|
||||
5.5,0.05,0.00024361759104975006,0.006010473696738872,0.005562788495679962,16804.0
|
||||
1.0,0.06,0.10860507246376812,0.8782608695652174,0.46511627906976744,115.0
|
||||
1.5,0.06,0.06986215538847118,0.7593984962406015,0.4291845493562232,133.0
|
||||
2.0,0.06,0.04661312849162011,0.5642458100558659,0.35842293906810035,179.0
|
||||
2.5,0.06,0.030640015015015017,0.45495495495495497,0.3105590062111801,222.0
|
||||
3.0,0.06,0.016866364421416234,0.2616580310880829,0.205761316872428,386.0
|
||||
3.5,0.06,0.01060005868544601,0.17781690140845072,0.1497005988023952,568.0
|
||||
4.0,0.06,0.004001374705420267,0.0793401413982718,0.07215743440233237,1273.0
|
||||
4.5,0.06,0.0022383317929759706,0.0466728280961183,0.044169611307420496,2164.0
|
||||
5.0,0.06,0.000717465361273331,0.017347990381312264,0.01622169651909429,5822.0
|
||||
5.5,0.06,0.000246610186169166,0.005962923603731255,0.0055774085598544005,16938.0
|
||||
1.0,0.07,0.10969202898550724,0.8782608695652174,0.4675925925925926,115.0
|
||||
1.5,0.07,0.06571588366890381,0.6778523489932886,0.40160642570281124,149.0
|
||||
2.0,0.07,0.048812984496124034,0.5872093023255814,0.36764705882352944,172.0
|
||||
2.5,0.07,0.031203497023809524,0.45089285714285715,0.30864197530864196,224.0
|
||||
3.0,0.07,0.016545734388742305,0.26649076517150394,0.21041666666666667,379.0
|
||||
3.5,0.07,0.010585281774580336,0.18165467625899281,0.1524390243902439,556.0
|
||||
4.0,0.07,0.004550533448673587,0.08737024221453288,0.07961783439490445,1156.0
|
||||
4.5,0.07,0.0024309055779569893,0.05090725806451613,0.04798464491362764,1984.0
|
||||
5.0,0.07,0.0008353080568720379,0.01914691943127962,0.018422032005954596,5275.0
|
||||
5.5,0.07,0.0002663176322917355,0.006672392151681311,0.0061063690085357844,15137.0
|
||||
1.0,0.08,0.10510587431693989,0.8278688524590164,0.452914798206278,122.0
|
||||
1.5,0.08,0.06693412162162163,0.6824324324324325,0.4032258064516129,148.0
|
||||
2.0,0.08,0.05258534136546185,0.608433734939759,0.37593984962406013,166.0
|
||||
2.5,0.08,0.03162369207772795,0.452914798206278,0.30959752321981426,223.0
|
||||
3.0,0.08,0.017741755793226382,0.2700534759358289,0.2109704641350211,374.0
|
||||
3.5,0.08,0.011236404350607805,0.19385796545105566,0.1610305958132045,521.0
|
||||
4.0,0.08,0.004819789816459443,0.08969804618117229,0.08156606851549755,1126.0
|
||||
4.5,0.08,0.0022914712320200124,0.0473733583489681,0.044802867383512544,2132.0
|
||||
5.0,0.08,0.0007240003432297924,0.01733310451347177,0.01637407157326131,5827.0
|
||||
5.5,0.08,0.00029078074988568814,0.006927297668038409,0.00633817215293396,14580.0
|
||||
1.0,0.09,0.10451388888888889,0.8416666666666667,0.45701357466063347,120.0
|
||||
1.5,0.09,0.06689342403628118,0.6870748299319728,0.4024390243902439,147.0
|
||||
2.0,0.09,0.051277281746031744,0.6011904761904762,0.373134328358209,168.0
|
||||
2.5,0.09,0.03066588785046729,0.4719626168224299,0.32063492063492066,214.0
|
||||
3.0,0.09,0.018720657276995307,0.28450704225352114,0.22149122807017543,355.0
|
||||
3.5,0.09,0.011574074074074073,0.20404040404040405,0.16806722689075632,495.0
|
||||
4.0,0.09,0.004629629629629629,0.0890652557319224,0.08029197080291971,1134.0
|
||||
4.5,0.09,0.0025395778364116096,0.05329815303430079,0.04917210235825389,1895.0
|
||||
5.0,0.09,0.0007872295546314711,0.018260712348580725,0.01758436944937833,5531.0
|
||||
5.5,0.09,0.0002889495751958513,0.006686527639854353,0.006119226213975523,15105.0
|
||||
1.0,0.1,0.10545798898071625,0.8347107438016529,0.45248868778280543,121.0
|
||||
1.5,0.1,0.06906392694063927,0.6917808219178082,0.4065040650406504,146.0
|
||||
2.0,0.1,0.05580849889624724,0.6688741721854304,0.398406374501992,151.0
|
||||
2.5,0.1,0.03563874788494078,0.5126903553299492,0.3367003367003367,197.0
|
||||
3.0,0.1,0.021444187242798354,0.3117283950617284,0.2376470588235294,324.0
|
||||
3.5,0.1,0.008698775612193904,0.15142428785607195,0.1303780964797914,667.0
|
||||
4.0,0.1,0.0038456648868548183,0.07704042715484363,0.07021276595744681,1311.0
|
||||
4.5,0.1,0.0024552461461959225,0.05022376926902039,0.046467520151730675,2011.0
|
||||
5.0,0.1,0.000777282433056325,0.017486149584487534,0.016683690840994213,5776.0
|
||||
5.5,0.1,0.00027746712755862815,0.0068456011928968415,0.0067990575563783235,14754.0
|
||||
1.0,0.11,0.10795454545454546,0.8347107438016529,0.45248868778280543,121.0
|
||||
1.5,0.11,0.07104885057471265,0.696551724137931,0.4105691056910569,145.0
|
||||
2.0,0.11,0.056901041666666666,0.63125,0.38461538461538464,160.0
|
||||
2.5,0.11,0.03851495726495727,0.517948717948718,0.3389830508474576,195.0
|
||||
3.0,0.11,0.023148148148148147,0.3117283950617284,0.2376470588235294,324.0
|
||||
3.5,0.11,0.010226644555002764,0.16749585406301823,0.14102564102564102,603.0
|
||||
4.0,0.11,0.0054902659069325736,0.09591642924976258,0.08752166377816291,1053.0
|
||||
4.5,0.11,0.0022757548845470693,0.044849023090586145,0.04129416773094934,2252.0
|
||||
5.0,0.11,0.0009444177093358999,0.01944177093358999,0.019070996978851965,5195.0
|
||||
5.5,0.11,0.0003233679758851847,0.0068160345525711975,0.006769890743347409,14818.0
|
||||
1.0,0.12,0.1497844827586207,0.8706896551724138,0.46296296296296297,116.0
|
||||
1.5,0.12,0.11599310776942356,0.7593984962406015,0.4291845493562232,133.0
|
||||
2.0,0.12,0.09710081585081586,0.7062937062937062,0.4139344262295082,143.0
|
||||
2.5,0.12,0.07447638146167558,0.5401069518716578,0.34615384615384615,187.0
|
||||
3.0,0.12,0.04418742586002373,0.3594306049822064,0.2643979057591623,281.0
|
||||
3.5,0.12,0.03012609649122807,0.2657894736842105,0.20668058455114824,380.0
|
||||
4.0,0.12,0.013963560334528077,0.12066905615292713,0.10576923076923077,837.0
|
||||
4.5,0.12,0.008003897550111359,0.07498144023756496,0.0691085003455425,1347.0
|
||||
5.0,0.12,0.004985032831208961,0.03901120123599845,0.03718854592785422,2589.0
|
||||
5.5,0.12,0.002348762603116407,0.01851512373968836,0.01658554173427078,5455.0
|
||||
1.0,0.13,0.2574961059190031,0.9439252336448598,0.4855769230769231,107.0
|
||||
1.5,0.13,0.23152173913043478,0.8782608695652174,0.4675925925925926,115.0
|
||||
2.0,0.13,0.21479885057471265,0.8706896551724138,0.46543778801843316,116.0
|
||||
2.5,0.13,0.16532939189189189,0.6824324324324325,0.40562248995983935,148.0
|
||||
3.0,0.13,0.1294191919191919,0.51010101010101,0.3377926421404682,198.0
|
||||
3.5,0.13,0.08825757575757576,0.36727272727272725,0.26666666666666666,275.0
|
||||
4.0,0.13,0.06085526315789474,0.2531328320802005,0.20040080160320642,399.0
|
||||
4.5,0.13,0.05009814418272662,0.21627408993576017,0.17491166077738515,467.0
|
||||
5.0,0.13,0.03163265306122449,0.13741496598639455,0.11764705882352941,735.0
|
||||
5.5,0.13,0.023883119024068578,0.09990108803165183,0.08589511754068715,1011.0
|
||||
1.0,0.14,0.3316783489096573,0.9439252336448598,0.4830917874396135,107.0
|
||||
1.5,0.14,0.3262924382716049,0.9351851851851852,0.4782608695652174,108.0
|
||||
2.0,0.14,0.3117559523809524,0.9017857142857143,0.47417840375586856,112.0
|
||||
2.5,0.14,0.27468832020997375,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
3.0,0.14,0.2322557471264368,0.696551724137931,0.4057377049180328,145.0
|
||||
3.5,0.14,0.20638805220883535,0.608433734939759,0.37358490566037733,166.0
|
||||
4.0,0.14,0.1875,0.5459459459459459,0.3485915492957746,185.0
|
||||
4.5,0.14,0.1155459295929593,0.3333333333333333,0.24813895781637718,303.0
|
||||
5.0,0.14,0.12193181818181818,0.36727272727272725,0.26861702127659576,275.0
|
||||
5.5,0.14,0.11617772108843537,0.3435374149659864,0.25,294.0
|
||||
1.0,0.15,0.38882211538461536,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
1.5,0.15,0.3895016339869281,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.0,0.15,0.3606651376146789,0.926605504587156,0.4784688995215311,109.0
|
||||
2.5,0.15,0.3293269230769231,0.8632478632478633,0.4608294930875576,117.0
|
||||
3.0,0.15,0.29605263157894735,0.7593984962406015,0.4291845493562232,133.0
|
||||
3.5,0.15,0.29068538647342995,0.7318840579710145,0.4225941422594142,138.0
|
||||
4.0,0.15,0.20591709621993126,0.520618556701031,0.3401360544217687,194.0
|
||||
4.5,0.15,0.22678571428571428,0.5771428571428572,0.36363636363636365,175.0
|
||||
5.0,0.15,0.16237997256515774,0.4156378600823045,0.2915451895043732,243.0
|
||||
5.5,0.15,0.16196646341463414,0.4105691056910569,0.2910662824207493,246.0
|
||||
1.0,0.16,0.4251237623762376,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.16,0.41061507936507935,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
2.0,0.16,0.39897798742138363,0.9528301886792453,0.48792270531400966,106.0
|
||||
2.5,0.16,0.4084325396825397,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
3.0,0.16,0.36117097701149425,0.8706896551724138,0.46543778801843316,116.0
|
||||
3.5,0.16,0.3315288713910761,0.7952755905511811,0.44052863436123346,127.0
|
||||
4.0,0.16,0.3414713541666667,0.7890625,0.4410480349344978,128.0
|
||||
4.5,0.16,0.28716216216216217,0.6824324324324325,0.40562248995983935,148.0
|
||||
5.0,0.16,0.2544286427145709,0.6047904191616766,0.376865671641791,167.0
|
||||
5.5,0.16,0.2061084142394822,0.49029126213592233,0.3289902280130293,206.0
|
||||
|
@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"duration": 11.816431743005523,
|
||||
"name": "2d_BER_FER_DFR_963965",
|
||||
"platform": "Linux-6.1.6-arch1-3-x86_64-with-glibc2.36",
|
||||
"omega": 0.05,
|
||||
"K": 200,
|
||||
"end_time": "2023-01-23 21:20:22.718490"
|
||||
}
|
||||
171
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_bch_31_26.csv
Normal file
171
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_bch_31_26.csv
Normal file
@ -0,0 +1,171 @@
|
||||
SNR,gamma,BER,FER,DFR,num_iterations
|
||||
1.0,0.0,0.07585004359197908,0.9099099099099099,0.47393364928909953,111.0
|
||||
1.5,0.0,0.06950146627565983,0.9181818181818182,0.47368421052631576,110.0
|
||||
2.0,0.0,0.05446853516657853,0.8278688524590164,0.4479638009049774,122.0
|
||||
2.5,0.0,0.04020570359981299,0.7318840579710145,0.4177215189873418,138.0
|
||||
3.0,0.0,0.039220236713854724,0.7266187050359713,0.42083333333333334,139.0
|
||||
3.5,0.0,0.029731830547998446,0.608433734939759,0.3782771535580524,166.0
|
||||
4.0,0.0,0.018621700879765397,0.4590909090909091,0.3146417445482866,220.0
|
||||
4.5,0.0,0.015253813453363341,0.39147286821705424,0.28133704735376047,258.0
|
||||
5.0,0.0,0.010213635202995999,0.26649076517150394,0.21041666666666667,379.0
|
||||
5.5,0.0,0.007438820912124583,0.21767241379310345,0.17876106194690267,464.0
|
||||
1.0,0.01,0.07142857142857142,0.7214285714285714,0.3721973094170404,140.0
|
||||
1.5,0.01,0.0685189545561573,0.7372262773722628,0.38839285714285715,137.0
|
||||
2.0,0.01,0.04990512333965844,0.5941176470588235,0.32806324110671936,170.0
|
||||
2.5,0.01,0.030631607481702357,0.42436974789915966,0.26993865030674846,238.0
|
||||
3.0,0.01,0.02347897100857493,0.31962025316455694,0.21975308641975308,316.0
|
||||
3.5,0.01,0.016738441537336474,0.25440806045340053,0.18813905930470348,397.0
|
||||
4.0,0.01,0.00939604059893478,0.1573208722741433,0.12534059945504086,642.0
|
||||
4.5,0.01,0.006917643632126993,0.11399548532731377,0.09406952965235174,886.0
|
||||
5.0,0.01,0.002671150008641956,0.049196298100340964,0.042890442890442894,2053.0
|
||||
5.5,0.01,0.0014380859076569086,0.02814154360546113,0.024728260869565217,3589.0
|
||||
1.0,0.02,0.07059069962295769,0.6558441558441559,0.32158590308370044,154.0
|
||||
1.5,0.02,0.06981882456915599,0.6917808219178082,0.35398230088495575,146.0
|
||||
2.0,0.02,0.05271889400921659,0.5771428571428572,0.30278884462151395,175.0
|
||||
2.5,0.02,0.031890101803017296,0.3840304182509506,0.23323615160349853,263.0
|
||||
3.0,0.02,0.024731182795698924,0.30606060606060603,0.19117647058823528,330.0
|
||||
3.5,0.02,0.016907187323146576,0.22149122807017543,0.1524163568773234,456.0
|
||||
4.0,0.02,0.008518855065879146,0.11854460093896714,0.08681672025723473,852.0
|
||||
4.5,0.02,0.006623328836011284,0.09600760456273764,0.07638279192273925,1052.0
|
||||
5.0,0.02,0.002590328632814864,0.03789868667917448,0.031613372093023256,2665.0
|
||||
5.5,0.02,0.001295973269783554,0.019230769230769232,0.014818983305196024,5252.0
|
||||
1.0,0.03,0.06867845993756504,0.6516129032258065,0.31718061674008813,155.0
|
||||
1.5,0.03,0.05598813496477568,0.5804597701149425,0.3203125,174.0
|
||||
2.0,0.03,0.051830373323667994,0.5674157303370787,0.29365079365079366,178.0
|
||||
2.5,0.03,0.03123804666581665,0.39920948616600793,0.23333333333333334,253.0
|
||||
3.0,0.03,0.020853698273053112,0.255050505050505,0.16981132075471697,396.0
|
||||
3.5,0.03,0.018607488751620528,0.23877068557919623,0.15904572564612326,423.0
|
||||
4.0,0.03,0.008651873951146746,0.11676300578034682,0.08658922914466737,865.0
|
||||
4.5,0.03,0.006378234978692179,0.08836395450568679,0.06997558991049634,1143.0
|
||||
5.0,0.03,0.0027239022421750862,0.03948397185301016,0.03362296939931998,2558.0
|
||||
5.5,0.03,0.0012959265875100697,0.01827723488961274,0.013742637872568266,5526.0
|
||||
1.0,0.04,0.06823821339950373,0.6474358974358975,0.30973451327433627,156.0
|
||||
1.5,0.04,0.06786761625471303,0.6558441558441559,0.32751091703056767,154.0
|
||||
2.0,0.04,0.04918032786885246,0.5519125683060109,0.28793774319066145,183.0
|
||||
2.5,0.04,0.034442873666623824,0.40239043824701193,0.22291021671826625,251.0
|
||||
3.0,0.04,0.024012323305545487,0.28370786516853935,0.17592592592592593,356.0
|
||||
3.5,0.04,0.01824551160414538,0.22850678733031674,0.15487571701720843,442.0
|
||||
4.0,0.04,0.00843561058614822,0.11335578002244669,0.08333333333333333,891.0
|
||||
4.5,0.04,0.006131241714538224,0.08647260273972603,0.0685805422647528,1168.0
|
||||
5.0,0.04,0.002673730596885599,0.03875671527244819,0.033024118738404454,2606.0
|
||||
5.5,0.04,0.0013585492848165659,0.018738404452690167,0.013723696248856358,5390.0
|
||||
1.0,0.05,0.06718717896034518,0.643312101910828,0.31140350877192985,157.0
|
||||
1.5,0.05,0.0661494487545937,0.6392405063291139,0.3218884120171674,158.0
|
||||
2.0,0.05,0.05079308501158439,0.5580110497237569,0.29571984435797666,181.0
|
||||
2.5,0.05,0.031607700312174816,0.40725806451612906,0.2392638036809816,248.0
|
||||
3.0,0.05,0.02535950252623397,0.3042168674698795,0.18427518427518427,332.0
|
||||
3.5,0.05,0.01818181818181818,0.22954545454545455,0.15221579961464354,440.0
|
||||
4.0,0.05,0.00959242319990286,0.12672521957340024,0.09225512528473805,797.0
|
||||
4.5,0.05,0.006309506892141537,0.08898678414096917,0.07195421095666395,1135.0
|
||||
5.0,0.05,0.00286888005926325,0.042171189979123176,0.03466344216041919,2395.0
|
||||
5.5,0.05,0.0013774794630334601,0.019604037267080744,0.01510227489963678,5152.0
|
||||
1.0,0.06,0.07658688865764829,0.6516129032258065,0.2986425339366516,155.0
|
||||
1.5,0.06,0.06632837984777093,0.5674157303370787,0.29365079365079366,178.0
|
||||
2.0,0.06,0.055200966016905294,0.5401069518716578,0.26666666666666666,187.0
|
||||
2.5,0.06,0.04103324681745149,0.38697318007662834,0.2018348623853211,261.0
|
||||
3.0,0.06,0.025357499168606586,0.2603092783505155,0.15835140997830802,388.0
|
||||
3.5,0.06,0.01972079154242342,0.21218487394957983,0.1407942238267148,476.0
|
||||
4.0,0.06,0.00978494623655914,0.11222222222222222,0.07692307692307693,900.0
|
||||
4.5,0.06,0.00609199720895282,0.08402662229617304,0.06893880712625872,1202.0
|
||||
5.0,0.06,0.0027946638640407974,0.03739355794150315,0.031205164992826398,2701.0
|
||||
5.5,0.06,0.0014139377270801887,0.018679489550582577,0.01332116788321168,5407.0
|
||||
1.0,0.07,0.12405282528685863,0.6778523489932886,0.2766990291262136,149.0
|
||||
1.5,0.07,0.09492028179458657,0.5804597701149425,0.27800829875518673,174.0
|
||||
2.0,0.07,0.11432116270825948,0.554945054945055,0.2571428571428571,182.0
|
||||
2.5,0.07,0.06734352910936897,0.40239043824701193,0.17973856209150327,251.0
|
||||
3.0,0.07,0.053402005963675794,0.28291316526610644,0.13349514563106796,357.0
|
||||
3.5,0.07,0.03186387228171605,0.20570264765784113,0.12321428571428572,491.0
|
||||
4.0,0.07,0.0234468339307049,0.11689814814814815,0.06290672451193059,864.0
|
||||
4.5,0.07,0.01270772238514174,0.08744588744588745,0.060211554109031735,1155.0
|
||||
5.0,0.07,0.006274571064073525,0.04075867635189669,0.025560361777428233,2478.0
|
||||
5.5,0.07,0.0028845455685591135,0.0206670759156947,0.013524424707307227,4887.0
|
||||
1.0,0.08,0.182328190743338,0.7318840579710145,0.29949238578680204,138.0
|
||||
1.5,0.08,0.12381129964572068,0.5838150289017341,0.24782608695652175,173.0
|
||||
2.0,0.08,0.13440860215053763,0.5260416666666666,0.20987654320987653,192.0
|
||||
2.5,0.08,0.09911772814998622,0.43162393162393164,0.1958762886597938,234.0
|
||||
3.0,0.08,0.07541774640335984,0.27977839335180055,0.13842482100238662,361.0
|
||||
3.5,0.08,0.06018882769472856,0.20528455284552846,0.11669658886894076,492.0
|
||||
4.0,0.08,0.04350280032996136,0.13593539703903096,0.06775407779171895,743.0
|
||||
4.5,0.08,0.030346963656133645,0.10316649642492338,0.06583969465648855,979.0
|
||||
5.0,0.08,0.014361372859206273,0.04307036247334755,0.026567040265670402,2345.0
|
||||
5.5,0.08,0.006640913568086678,0.024093511450381678,0.01526896875734085,4192.0
|
||||
1.0,0.09,0.29746367889682346,0.7709923664122137,0.27624309392265195,131.0
|
||||
1.5,0.09,0.22641509433962265,0.6352201257861635,0.2638888888888889,159.0
|
||||
2.0,0.09,0.18493401759530792,0.5738636363636364,0.2314410480349345,176.0
|
||||
2.5,0.09,0.19055861526357198,0.4926829268292683,0.21153846153846154,205.0
|
||||
3.0,0.09,0.09714928732183045,0.2936046511627907,0.14640198511166252,344.0
|
||||
3.5,0.09,0.0644494801386297,0.20867768595041322,0.12,484.0
|
||||
4.0,0.09,0.059809624537281864,0.16557377049180327,0.08132530120481928,610.0
|
||||
4.5,0.09,0.03724608669970138,0.10274669379450661,0.052986512524084775,983.0
|
||||
5.0,0.09,0.02243519496303971,0.062384187770228534,0.031119090365050867,1619.0
|
||||
5.5,0.09,0.012482709013445472,0.034648370497427104,0.015202702702702704,2915.0
|
||||
1.0,0.1,0.34069478908188583,0.7769230769230769,0.26136363636363635,130.0
|
||||
1.5,0.1,0.3058542413381123,0.7481481481481481,0.23295454545454544,135.0
|
||||
2.0,0.1,0.2742878702131673,0.5906432748538012,0.21559633027522937,171.0
|
||||
2.5,0.1,0.20332798131659613,0.45701357466063347,0.15648854961832062,221.0
|
||||
3.0,0.1,0.14913510986442263,0.36594202898550726,0.14285714285714285,276.0
|
||||
3.5,0.1,0.09198413292418232,0.23433874709976799,0.09832635983263599,431.0
|
||||
4.0,0.1,0.08395293015631403,0.18330308529945555,0.08166666666666667,551.0
|
||||
4.5,0.1,0.05740649699353326,0.11840562719812427,0.04049493813273341,853.0
|
||||
5.0,0.1,0.03869453278812661,0.07902973395931143,0.028136882129277566,1278.0
|
||||
5.5,0.1,0.0204410360212678,0.044631020768890854,0.01949740034662045,2263.0
|
||||
1.0,0.11,0.44111027756939236,0.7829457364341085,0.26704545454545453,129.0
|
||||
1.5,0.11,0.30016757436112274,0.6558441558441559,0.2413793103448276,154.0
|
||||
2.0,0.11,0.285047677013593,0.6352201257861635,0.22815533980582525,159.0
|
||||
2.5,0.11,0.2512272089761571,0.5489130434782609,0.19298245614035087,184.0
|
||||
3.0,0.11,0.15604155276107162,0.3423728813559322,0.14985590778097982,295.0
|
||||
3.5,0.11,0.1307300509337861,0.2657894736842105,0.10377358490566038,380.0
|
||||
4.0,0.11,0.09022822433213422,0.1846435100548446,0.06495726495726496,547.0
|
||||
4.5,0.11,0.06363750470691602,0.1309987029831388,0.04932182490752158,771.0
|
||||
5.0,0.11,0.04158537563139749,0.08367854183927093,0.032852564102564104,1207.0
|
||||
5.5,0.11,0.024072745376539324,0.04584657285519746,0.0160786065207682,2203.0
|
||||
1.0,0.12,0.3686635944700461,0.8015873015873016,0.2840909090909091,126.0
|
||||
1.5,0.12,0.3323888404533566,0.6824324324324325,0.24489795918367346,148.0
|
||||
2.0,0.12,0.29266862170087976,0.6121212121212121,0.24311926605504589,165.0
|
||||
2.5,0.12,0.23887096774193547,0.505,0.16666666666666666,200.0
|
||||
3.0,0.12,0.1956177723676202,0.38113207547169814,0.14790996784565916,265.0
|
||||
3.5,0.12,0.14758292972676598,0.28611898016997167,0.10632911392405063,353.0
|
||||
4.0,0.12,0.11147035050334338,0.23006833712984054,0.09670781893004116,439.0
|
||||
4.5,0.12,0.06464346349745331,0.13289473684210526,0.0594059405940594,760.0
|
||||
5.0,0.12,0.05474095796676442,0.10202020202020202,0.03696498054474708,990.0
|
||||
5.5,0.12,0.03271028037383177,0.05899532710280374,0.021714285714285714,1712.0
|
||||
1.0,0.13,0.3831945889698231,0.8145161290322581,0.2832369942196532,124.0
|
||||
1.5,0.13,0.3530340627114821,0.7062937062937062,0.27411167512690354,143.0
|
||||
2.0,0.13,0.322372528616025,0.6516129032258065,0.27230046948356806,155.0
|
||||
2.5,0.13,0.2628500531726338,0.554945054945055,0.2222222222222222,182.0
|
||||
3.0,0.13,0.20543959519291588,0.396078431372549,0.1611842105263158,255.0
|
||||
3.5,0.13,0.1576331582895724,0.2936046511627907,0.1134020618556701,344.0
|
||||
4.0,0.13,0.14013883217639853,0.25569620253164554,0.10633484162895927,395.0
|
||||
4.5,0.13,0.08928199791883455,0.1629032258064516,0.06766917293233082,620.0
|
||||
5.0,0.13,0.0567049057097101,0.10233029381965553,0.03988326848249027,987.0
|
||||
5.5,0.13,0.04593323449721384,0.08003169572107766,0.025482625482625483,1262.0
|
||||
1.0,0.14,0.3830005120327701,0.8015873015873016,0.2840909090909091,126.0
|
||||
1.5,0.14,0.35023041474654376,0.7593984962406015,0.2692307692307692,133.0
|
||||
2.0,0.14,0.35659425060346717,0.6870748299319728,0.24615384615384617,147.0
|
||||
2.5,0.14,0.28910856746444674,0.543010752688172,0.22821576763485477,186.0
|
||||
3.0,0.14,0.18365102639296188,0.38257575757575757,0.1592356687898089,264.0
|
||||
3.5,0.14,0.15388222055513878,0.2936046511627907,0.12020460358056266,344.0
|
||||
4.0,0.14,0.14191927378829633,0.2537688442211055,0.1036036036036036,398.0
|
||||
4.5,0.14,0.10066546356868937,0.17657342657342656,0.0848,572.0
|
||||
5.0,0.14,0.06809621480514637,0.11676300578034682,0.04419889502762431,865.0
|
||||
5.5,0.14,0.037988972344028135,0.06796769851951548,0.024294156270518712,1486.0
|
||||
1.0,0.15,0.4050179211469534,0.8632478632478633,0.3352272727272727,117.0
|
||||
1.5,0.15,0.3296728437428506,0.7163120567375887,0.29850746268656714,141.0
|
||||
2.0,0.15,0.35769701919150676,0.6392405063291139,0.2882882882882883,158.0
|
||||
2.5,0.15,0.29013611784449,0.5838150289017341,0.24782608695652175,173.0
|
||||
3.0,0.15,0.21948924731182795,0.42083333333333334,0.2079207920792079,240.0
|
||||
3.5,0.15,0.1787845080392355,0.3166144200626959,0.14016172506738545,319.0
|
||||
4.0,0.15,0.11805555555555555,0.2337962962962963,0.11293634496919917,432.0
|
||||
4.5,0.15,0.0756765020639046,0.15955766192733017,0.0718475073313783,633.0
|
||||
5.0,0.15,0.06440677966101695,0.11412429378531073,0.04838709677419355,885.0
|
||||
5.5,0.15,0.046331435800126504,0.08251633986928104,0.03622047244094488,1224.0
|
||||
1.0,0.16,0.47146401985111663,0.8632478632478633,0.3352272727272727,117.0
|
||||
1.5,0.16,0.3194971537001898,0.7426470588235294,0.3096446700507614,136.0
|
||||
2.0,0.16,0.374910394265233,0.7481481481481481,0.3076923076923077,135.0
|
||||
2.5,0.16,0.2666268418956591,0.6234567901234568,0.273542600896861,162.0
|
||||
3.0,0.16,0.19184369263047468,0.4105691056910569,0.18,246.0
|
||||
3.5,0.16,0.17089466541392628,0.3268608414239482,0.1510989010989011,309.0
|
||||
4.0,0.16,0.13593282341203858,0.2603092783505155,0.12612612612612611,388.0
|
||||
4.5,0.16,0.08454600785702429,0.1732418524871355,0.07313195548489666,583.0
|
||||
5.0,0.16,0.06474681840901227,0.12038140643623362,0.05090497737556561,839.0
|
||||
5.5,0.16,0.0342563516985441,0.06875425459496257,0.027796161482461945,1469.0
|
||||
|
@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"duration": 1.805683234008029,
|
||||
"name": "2d_BER_FER_DFR_bch_31_26",
|
||||
"platform": "Linux-6.1.6-arch1-3-x86_64-with-glibc2.36",
|
||||
"omega": 0.05,
|
||||
"K": 200,
|
||||
"end_time": "2023-01-23 21:32:02.418445"
|
||||
}
|
||||
171
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_pegreg252x504.csv
Normal file
171
latex/thesis/res/proximal/2d_ber_fer_dfr_pegreg252x504.csv
Normal file
@ -0,0 +1,171 @@
|
||||
SNR,gamma,BER,FER,DFR,num_iterations
|
||||
1.0,0.0,0.1312863429200063,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.0,0.11871365707999372,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.0,0.10225129655822725,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.0,0.08777306302058778,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.0,0.07916863114882917,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.0,0.06628162816281628,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.0,0.0575003928964325,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.0,0.04712792707842213,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.0,0.0,0.0374037403740374,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.5,0.0,0.02813138456702813,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.0,0.01,0.09604353292472104,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.01,0.07582901147257583,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.01,0.052353449630677354,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.01,0.03571428571428571,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.01,0.02585144089998459,0.9805825242718447,0.4950980392156863,103.0
|
||||
3.5,0.01,0.016099773242630386,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
4.0,0.01,0.007404181184668989,0.8211382113821138,0.45089285714285715,123.0
|
||||
4.5,0.01,0.0036620615324319027,0.6234567901234568,0.3840304182509506,162.0
|
||||
5.0,0.01,0.001527403414195867,0.38113207547169814,0.27595628415300544,265.0
|
||||
5.5,0.01,0.0006792852537533388,0.195357833655706,0.1634304207119741,517.0
|
||||
1.0,0.02,0.09343077164859342,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.02,0.0722929435800723,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.02,0.044915188297541236,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.5,0.02,0.02819349962207105,0.9619047619047619,0.49029126213592233,105.0
|
||||
3.0,0.02,0.018664840567495435,0.8938053097345132,0.4719626168224299,113.0
|
||||
3.5,0.02,0.008126074208876757,0.643312101910828,0.39147286821705424,157.0
|
||||
4.0,0.02,0.002737974622473103,0.3069908814589666,0.23488372093023255,329.0
|
||||
4.5,0.02,0.0009405074365704287,0.15905511811023623,0.13722826086956522,635.0
|
||||
5.0,0.02,0.00024244498638029634,0.04537286612758311,0.04340352385045122,2226.0
|
||||
5.5,0.02,7.243867243867244e-05,0.014690909090909091,0.014478211009174312,6875.0
|
||||
1.0,0.03,0.09374508879459374,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.03,0.07115354392582116,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.03,0.043378462496109556,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.5,0.03,0.02515527950310559,0.8782608695652174,0.4675925925925926,115.0
|
||||
3.0,0.03,0.013712220047836485,0.6917808219178082,0.4089068825910931,146.0
|
||||
3.5,0.03,0.00570959748174938,0.42616033755274263,0.2988165680473373,237.0
|
||||
4.0,0.03,0.0013284775189537094,0.14574314574314573,0.12720403022670027,693.0
|
||||
4.5,0.03,0.0004781593677045538,0.0596574128765505,0.05629877369007804,1693.0
|
||||
5.0,0.03,8.25122686274828e-05,0.011475968639927281,0.01134576499662997,8801.0
|
||||
5.5,0.03,1.9686505446046404e-05,0.00301843937718538,0.0030093558190811037,33461.0
|
||||
1.0,0.04,0.09457017130284456,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.04,0.07156608517994656,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.04,0.042582417582417584,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
2.5,0.04,0.022123015873015874,0.8416666666666667,0.45701357466063347,120.0
|
||||
3.0,0.04,0.01188195584747309,0.5804597701149425,0.36727272727272725,174.0
|
||||
3.5,0.04,0.004222174981103552,0.3005952380952381,0.2311212814645309,336.0
|
||||
4.0,0.04,0.0009012151869294727,0.0924908424908425,0.08466051969823973,1092.0
|
||||
4.5,0.04,0.00033092973839133315,0.036942209217264085,0.03562610229276896,2734.0
|
||||
5.0,0.04,5.291338079563754e-05,0.006352600792502673,0.0063125,15899.0
|
||||
5.5,0.04,1.191919191919192e-05,0.001469090909090909,0.0014669358469739002,68750.0
|
||||
1.0,0.05,0.09504164702184505,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.05,0.07347163287757347,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.05,0.04208638583638584,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
2.5,0.05,0.023059617547806523,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
3.0,0.05,0.010484749455337691,0.4950980392156863,0.33114754098360655,204.0
|
||||
3.5,0.05,0.0037675070028011202,0.2376470588235294,0.1920152091254753,425.0
|
||||
4.0,0.05,0.0008795184740562892,0.07072829131652661,0.06605624591236102,1428.0
|
||||
4.5,0.05,0.0002754500310366232,0.028212290502793298,0.02743819614235262,3580.0
|
||||
5.0,0.05,4.450739983899932e-05,0.004690692922162363,0.00466879304765867,21532.0
|
||||
5.5,0.05,1.10331208907129e-05,0.0012452993033721718,0.0012437504617885378,81105.0
|
||||
1.0,0.06,0.09594530881659595,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.06,0.07488606003457489,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.06,0.04673721340388007,0.9351851851851852,0.48325358851674644,108.0
|
||||
2.5,0.06,0.02305586317214224,0.7829457364341085,0.4391304347826087,129.0
|
||||
3.0,0.06,0.010818216175359033,0.48095238095238096,0.3247588424437299,210.0
|
||||
3.5,0.06,0.003532713898567557,0.22394678492239467,0.18297101449275363,451.0
|
||||
4.0,0.06,0.0008638644324529016,0.06693174287607687,0.06273291925465839,1509.0
|
||||
4.5,0.06,0.0002779138561254098,0.02664204695331047,0.025950668036998973,3791.0
|
||||
5.0,0.06,4.3710114520500044e-05,0.004674411070486416,0.0046526626128616175,21607.0
|
||||
5.5,0.06,1.069084023682721e-05,0.0011830576769901139,0.0011816597054040458,85372.0
|
||||
1.0,0.07,0.09735973597359736,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.07,0.07594148770619359,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.0,0.07,0.047746468618028254,0.926605504587156,0.48095238095238096,109.0
|
||||
2.5,0.07,0.02316849816849817,0.7769230769230769,0.43722943722943725,130.0
|
||||
3.0,0.07,0.010128578360019408,0.4410480349344978,0.30606060606060603,229.0
|
||||
3.5,0.07,0.003671482838149505,0.21581196581196582,0.17750439367311072,468.0
|
||||
4.0,0.07,0.0008624471564170057,0.06344221105527638,0.0596574128765505,1592.0
|
||||
4.5,0.07,0.0002759316166019518,0.02526263131565783,0.02464015613564284,3998.0
|
||||
5.0,0.07,4.360139046240681e-05,0.004474768508262815,0.004454834156669019,22571.0
|
||||
5.5,0.07,1.073840582583297e-05,0.0011680081413636785,0.001166645489933351,86472.0
|
||||
1.0,0.08,0.09635785007072135,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.08,0.07675848117024588,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.0,0.08,0.048868312757201646,0.9351851851851852,0.48325358851674644,108.0
|
||||
2.5,0.08,0.023825146856642918,0.7952755905511811,0.44298245614035087,127.0
|
||||
3.0,0.08,0.010608117516012252,0.44298245614035087,0.3069908814589666,228.0
|
||||
3.5,0.08,0.003591674765144153,0.20612244897959184,0.17089678510998307,490.0
|
||||
4.0,0.08,0.0008916259732719562,0.0659699542782495,0.061887254901960786,1531.0
|
||||
4.5,0.08,0.0002860050311603272,0.02681178656756039,0.02611168562564633,3767.0
|
||||
5.0,0.08,4.66066981438279e-05,0.004726030602217959,0.004703800298062593,21371.0
|
||||
5.5,0.08,1.0967098516175105e-05,0.001198002538342012,0.001196569045588096,84307.0
|
||||
1.0,0.09,0.09704541882759704,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.09,0.07716697790227202,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.0,0.09,0.04908877131099353,0.9351851851851852,0.48325358851674644,108.0
|
||||
2.5,0.09,0.024021567914697686,0.7709923664122137,0.4353448275862069,131.0
|
||||
3.0,0.09,0.010953843903152658,0.46543778801843316,0.31761006289308175,217.0
|
||||
3.5,0.09,0.0037598372682406296,0.21218487394957983,0.17504332755632582,476.0
|
||||
4.0,0.09,0.00093346911065852,0.06856754921928038,0.06416772554002541,1473.0
|
||||
4.5,0.09,0.00029212212589521295,0.026649076517150396,0.02595733744538679,3790.0
|
||||
5.0,0.09,4.528625330258286e-05,0.00468547040267211,0.004663619153160641,21556.0
|
||||
5.5,0.09,1.1665886604377842e-05,0.001274335389934012,0.0012727135260465234,79257.0
|
||||
1.0,0.1,0.09781156687097281,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.1,0.07878151260504201,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.0,0.1,0.050356407995296885,0.9351851851851852,0.48325358851674644,108.0
|
||||
2.5,0.1,0.024733430267781412,0.7709923664122137,0.4353448275862069,131.0
|
||||
3.0,0.1,0.01115376056964842,0.4719626168224299,0.32063492063492066,214.0
|
||||
3.5,0.1,0.004183347380250035,0.2234513274336283,0.18264014466546113,452.0
|
||||
4.0,0.1,0.0009818919593355684,0.06903622693096377,0.06457800511508952,1463.0
|
||||
4.5,0.1,0.00028640956963505495,0.025136884021901444,0.024520514688031077,4018.0
|
||||
5.0,0.1,5.0714447353958554e-05,0.005142566191446029,0.0051162555088394715,19640.0
|
||||
5.5,0.1,1.274593993205766e-05,0.0013746172167403879,0.0013727302381211265,73475.0
|
||||
1.0,0.11,0.09948137670909948,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.11,0.08088235294117647,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.0,0.11,0.0522854203409759,0.9351851851851852,0.48325358851674644,108.0
|
||||
2.5,0.11,0.02676151761517615,0.8211382113821138,0.45089285714285715,123.0
|
||||
3.0,0.11,0.013256584685156114,0.554945054945055,0.3568904593639576,182.0
|
||||
3.5,0.11,0.004815305859389386,0.23433874709976799,0.18984962406015038,431.0
|
||||
4.0,0.11,0.0013205055649877383,0.08573853989813243,0.07896794370602032,1178.0
|
||||
4.5,0.11,0.0003229729502263967,0.0267762460233298,0.026077975729408728,3772.0
|
||||
5.0,0.11,7.112767529434196e-05,0.006318818818818819,0.006279142057817843,15984.0
|
||||
5.5,0.11,1.5814038471768328e-05,0.001471659624071106,0.001469497024632262,68630.0
|
||||
1.0,0.12,0.10885195662423386,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.12,0.08868269530034235,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
2.0,0.12,0.062082777036048066,0.9439252336448598,0.4855769230769231,107.0
|
||||
2.5,0.12,0.038088454755121424,0.8632478632478633,0.463302752293578,117.0
|
||||
3.0,0.12,0.02053627477356291,0.5706214689265536,0.36330935251798563,177.0
|
||||
3.5,0.12,0.010105535643170052,0.36200716845878134,0.2657894736842105,279.0
|
||||
4.0,0.12,0.0038131991822295728,0.14616497829232997,0.1275252525252525,691.0
|
||||
4.5,0.12,0.0013144700111120146,0.05748434832100171,0.05435952637244349,1757.0
|
||||
5.0,0.12,0.0005196623974662855,0.021576586199530016,0.02112086992890004,4681.0
|
||||
5.5,0.12,0.00024497833917330085,0.010056755949417505,0.009956624605678234,10043.0
|
||||
1.0,0.13,0.1617161716171617,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.13,0.14002828854314003,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.13,0.1191065535124941,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.13,0.10058148672010059,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.13,0.08352785558667912,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
3.5,0.13,0.07389900404606287,0.9901960784313726,0.4975369458128079,102.0
|
||||
4.0,0.13,0.06744177421747516,0.9439252336448598,0.4855769230769231,107.0
|
||||
4.5,0.13,0.06986416361416362,0.9711538461538461,0.4926829268292683,104.0
|
||||
5.0,0.13,0.0639703798185941,0.9017857142857143,0.47417840375586856,112.0
|
||||
5.5,0.13,0.06373572820941242,0.8859649122807017,0.4697674418604651,114.0
|
||||
1.0,0.14,0.25830975954738333,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.14,0.24825161087537326,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.14,0.23167138142385668,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.14,0.22012022630834513,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.14,0.2189022473675939,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.14,0.20825475404683325,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.14,0.20562234794908063,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.14,0.20226308345120225,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.0,0.14,0.20297029702970298,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.5,0.14,0.20365786578657866,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.0,0.15,0.34252710985384255,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.15,0.32993477919220493,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.15,0.32315731573157314,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.15,0.31337419456231336,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.15,0.3100935093509351,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.15,0.3085022787993085,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.15,0.30484834197705485,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.15,0.3024909633820525,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.0,0.15,0.30286421499292787,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.5,0.15,0.30934700612918437,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.0,0.16,0.41167688197391167,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
1.5,0.16,0.38963539211063963,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.0,0.16,0.3957645764576458,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
2.5,0.16,0.3932303944680182,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.0,0.16,0.3934857771491435,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
3.5,0.16,0.38454738330975957,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.0,0.16,0.38607967939651106,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
4.5,0.16,0.38446880402325945,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.0,0.16,0.37574650322175074,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
5.5,0.16,0.374017758918749,1.0,0.5,101.0
|
||||
|
@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"duration": 3634.816580417013,
|
||||
"name": "2d_BER_FER_DFR_pegreg252x504",
|
||||
"platform": "Linux-6.1.6-arch1-3-x86_64-with-glibc2.36",
|
||||
"omega": 0.05,
|
||||
"K": 200,
|
||||
"end_time": "2023-01-23 23:15:08.602126"
|
||||
}
|
||||
11
latex/thesis/res/proximal/ber_paper.csv
Normal file
11
latex/thesis/res/proximal/ber_paper.csv
Normal file
@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
|
||||
SNR,gamma_0_15,gamma_0_05,gamma_0_01,BP
|
||||
1,0.3669767287,0.0983527875,0.09440942764,0.06443019397
|
||||
1.5,0.3669767287,0.07297050292,0.07602178383,0.03398665526
|
||||
2,0.3669767287,0.04854153852,0.05563899358,0.01257341759
|
||||
2.5,0.3669767287,0.03099619799,0.03962553082,0.003089064275
|
||||
3,0.3669767287,0.01635036356,0.02635975022,0.001038700586
|
||||
3.5,0.3669767287,0.007422688173,0.01572148666,0.0001272453028
|
||||
4,0.3669767287,0.002980400475,0.008639663866,0
|
||||
4.5,0.3669767287,0.001044021313,0.004434697304,0
|
||||
5,0.3669767287,0.0003969287889,0.002126155473,0
|
||||
5.5,0.3908851459,0.00008863357225,0.0007759378638,0
|
||||
|
Loading…
Reference in New Issue
Block a user